Bigger surprise…..

[Sarge]

Justin Fields, Sam Darnold or Malik Willis?

 

[steelcan58]

Justin Fields, Sam Darnold or Malik Willis?

None. These supposed busts are all in a better situation. Except for Mahomes, Rodgers and Allen I don't believe the rest of the QBs can overcome bad situations.

For the most part franchise QBs are a myth.

 

[BLITZ]

Darnold

 

[stillwright]

Justin Fields, Sam Darnold or Malik Willis?

Honestly I don't care about Darnold or Malik. Just want Fields to keep playing solid football.....but I will go with Fields.

 

[jitter77]

Going with Darnold he has been lights out....

 

[Fiji Mariner]

Darnold

Going with Darnold too as I fully expected Fields to improve after leaving Chicago, not surprised by his play.

 

[madinsomniac]

None. These supposed busts are all in a better situation. Except for Mahomes, Rodgers and Allen I don't believe the rest of the QBs can overcome bad situations.

For the most part franchise QBs are a myth.

Nah, franchise QBs are real... but they are generational types.. only a couple per decade or so are like that... since the late 90's you have Manning, Brady, Rodgers, Brees, and Ben.. that was a ton of all timers at once and a whole bunch of great guys below that... now you have Mahomes... maybe Burrow... not really much else... some real good ones... but no one who is certain to be an all timer...

Maybe a stroud or purdy, but they have a long way to go

 

[Djfan]

Nah, franchise QBs are real... but they are generational types.. only a couple per decade or so are like that... since the late 90's you have Manning, Brady, Rodgers, Brees, and Ben.. that was a ton of all timers at once and a whole bunch of great guys below that... now you have Mahomes... maybe Burrow... not really much else... some real good ones... but no one who is certain to be an all timer...

Maybe a stroud or purdy, but they have a long way to go

I would put Allen over Burrow.

 

[madinsomniac]

I would put Allen over Burrow.

Fair, but he has to at least make a SB first..

 

[slashsteel]

Justin Fields, Sam Darnold or Malik Willis?

Darnold. I think he is playing pro bowl level. Fields second and wut you talkin bout Willis third.

 

[Buck Iron]

Going with Darnold too as I fully expected Fields to improve after leaving Chicago, not surprised by his play.

same here.

 

[Ironcitysteelers]

Sam. Finally on a complete team with a quality HC who can get a lot out of QBs.

 

[CoolieMan]

Fields

couldn't tell you what the others have done

 

[Frosty]

Gotta add Andy Dalton. Replaces Bryce Young ad had three td passes so far as the Panthers are pounding the Raiders in Vegas.

 

[jitter77]

Gotta add Andy Dalton. Replaces Bryce Young ad had three td passes so far as the Panthers are pounding the Raiders in Vegas.

Dalton usually looks good a few games then falls apart. Still impressive to do what he is doing w/ what looked to be the worst team in the league.

 

[SteelerFan448]

Darnold has the tools and periodically looks good. Right now he's in a great situation in Minnesota with that roster and coaching. Not surprised he's playing well.

Fields hasn't been lighting it up, but showing more each week. He's in the opposite situation as Darnold in the sense the offense is ultra conservative.

Willis is the biggest surprise because I thought he was a total bust.

 

[jitter77]

DJ has 8 catches for 122 yrds with Dalton throwing to him.

I also thought Greenbay was cooked when love went down. Willis is playing within the system and getting wins

 

[Fiji Mariner]

Fields

couldn't tell you what the others have done

Considering how bad Malik looked last year it is apparent he’s put in some work and maybe the Titans (post Arthur Smith) have an OC/QB coach as incompetent as Canada was.

Malik moves to GB and doesn’t look like *** any more. While Levis in TEN resembles what Willis was there in TEN.

We may have a Mason sighting in TEN next week haha

 

[Omar10213245]

Easily Willis