• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Carnell Lake

Darren Woodson is a finalist this year - let's compare

Carnell Lake - 1 1st Team All Pro, 4 2nd Team All Pro, 5 Pro-bowls, 1990s All decade team. 826 career tackles, 16 int, 25 sacks, 15 forced fumbles, 5 TDs - played in 1 Superbowl

Darren Woodson - 4 1st Team All Pro, 5 Pro-bowls, 1350 career tackles, 23 int, 11 sacks, 17 forced fumbles, 2 TDs - 3 Superbowls

He deserves at least some consideration.
 
Darren Woodson is a finalist this year - let's compare

Carnell Lake - 1 1st Team All Pro, 4 2nd Team All Pro, 5 Pro-bowls, 1990s All decade team. 826 career tackles, 16 int, 25 sacks, 15 forced fumbles, 5 TDs - played in 1 Superbowl

Darren Woodson - 4 1st Team All Pro, 5 Pro-bowls, 1350 career tackles, 23 int, 11 sacks, 17 forced fumbles, 2 TDs - 3 Superbowls

He deserves at least some consideration.
I don't think Woodsen is a HoFer. He's no Ronde Barber.
 
When do this year’s nominees list come out?

Did I miss it?



Salute the nation
 
I love Lake, but he really will never be recognized as a HOFer league wide. Though when Rod went down we moved that SS to CB and he became a shutdown CB for us that year and we made it to the SB because of him. It's like Aaron Smith, and Casey Hampton. Extremely talented guys that won't get in the hall because of stats.

I do think Hines will eventually get in. Lloyd also has a chance. That's it for those teams IMHO.
 
I love Lake, but he really will never be recognized as a HOFer league wide. Though when Rod went down we moved that SS to CB and he became a shutdown CB for us that year and we made it to the SB because of him. It's like Aaron Smith, and Casey Hampton. Extremely talented guys that won't get in the hall because of stats.

I do think Hines will eventually get in. Lloyd also has a chance. That's it for those teams IMHO.

LLoyd, will draw attention once Hines is inducted, until then he is sort of a “forgotten” commodity.


Salute the nation
 
LLoyd, will draw attention once Hines is inducted, until then he is sort of a “forgotten” commodity.


Salute the nation
Lloyd won’t get In because he was a total dick to the writers and to players on other teams… by being a dick to the writers, he ensured that they won’t ever voter for him… and the Vet committee isn’t going to either….
He was great, but not the slam dunk guy that could afford to be a total douche to everyone and tgey had to ignore it great…
 
Lloyd won’t get In because he was a total dick to the writers and to players on other teams… by being a dick to the writers, he ensured that they won’t ever voter for him… and the Vet committee isn’t going to either….
He was great, but not the slam dunk guy that could afford to be a total douche to everyone and tgey had to ignore it great…

Once Hines is in, the amount of attention LLoyd will generate more than likely will not be enough to get in, but still will draw attention.


Salute the nation
 
Top