• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Does Mitchell Trubisky have the “It” Factor?

Steeler Nation

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
2,542
Reaction score
4,985
Points
93
When new Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Mitchell Trubisky was drafted with the 2nd overall pick in 2017 by the Chicago Bears, it raised a lot of eyebrows. Trubisky started only one season at North Carolina, a 3,700-yard, 30 TD campaign propelled him from an unknown, to a top-level prospect leading up to the NFL Draft.

The questions surrounding Trubisky were significant. His 13 starts were the fewest of any 1st round pick QB since 2002. He threw just 572 passes in his college career. He had a Sun Bowl loss to Stanford in which he both shined and struggled. Meanwhile, Deshaun Watson had just beaten Alabama in for the National Championship in spectacular fashion.

Scouts were divided on whether Trubisky should return for his senior season vs. entering the draft. Or if you were Mel Kiper, you just covered yourself by saying both:

Mel Kiper, per ESPN draft night coverage (upon the selection of Trubisky):

“I thought needed to go back for another season.”

Mel Kiper, per ESPN (on projecting Trubisky as the #2 overall pick over Watson prior to the draft):

“If you look at the overall body of work of Trubisky this year, he had a great season overall. (Trubisky) is best equipped to be a great NFL QB.”



But the biggest question was how he was unable to beat out starter Marquise Williams for two years, a player most viewed as inferior in terms of talent.

UNC Head Coach Larry Fedora, per ESPN Senior Writer Tim Keown:

“It’s not always the most talented guy who gets the job. Sometimes it’s the guy who fits best with the other guys.”

A frustrated Trubisky never complained about not starting, but he questioned it. Raised in a mentality instilled in him by his parents, he followed the advice of his mother: “Don’t complain about it. Do something about it. Change it.”



Instilled by this, Trubisky said he would knock on Fedora’s door each week with the same question: What can I do to get better this week? The answer was always back to the same thing: “Presence.”

Fedora believed that a quarterback cannot lead only by example, but need to be loud, forceful, and occasionally arrogant. Qualities that do not come naturally to Trubisky.

As a result, a consensus formed that Trubisky lacked the “it” factor.

At UNC, while his teammates liked him, they rallied around Williams. Trubisky had the talent, but seemed to lack the swagger, confidence, and energy that a great QB inherently exudes. It was not through a lack of effort, as Trubisky would get with teammates like former Steelers wide receiver Ryan Switzer and go into the team practice facility at night and perfect their craft. He kept busy in the weight room, arriving at UNC at a meagre 195 pounds and played the 2016 season at a lean and muscular 225 pounds.

There was a never a question that he wasn’t a great teammate. He grew up with a banner hung over the the fireplace that read “Do what is right, not easy.” He’s always been viewed as a guy willing to do the work.

The question is, can Trubisky become more and play with both the confidence and moxie that matches his talent as the Steelers QB?



What do yinz think? Click to comment below!

#SteelerNation

Support SteelerNation by clicking here to read the story..
 
We’ll see… the beauty of football is its play on the grass not on paper… there is good reason to believe Mitch could be a steal. The big knock on him was lack of playing time in college his college team went to a running offense and he had a good qb in front of him. But he got valuable playing time with the bears in a harsh media market. I think he held up better than the coach did. but he never really sold himself to the Chicago media which is responsible for the bears never sticking with a qb letting him develop they run em right out of town. I just hope the Steelers dont draft a qb in the first or second… give him a chance, go all in on the guy who wins the qb competition and if they stink it up, go back to the drawing board but this drafting a guy in waiting just suks. Taking a qb in this draft will just be a waste if he’s not good enough to step in day one like Ben did.
 
I think that if swagger and a sense of self-importance made a QB any better, Ryan Leaf and Jamarcus Russell would have been All-Pros.
Self-importance and self confidence are two different things.

There’s a hint of truth in this. Don’t fool yourself into thinking Ben wasn’t arrogant.

I wouldn’t confuse Leaf’s inflated sense of himself vs. Trubisky. Trubisky has shown he’s willing to put in all the work. But when you’re in that huddle leading a bunch of very testosterone filled men, being a “nice” guy isn’t enough
 
Maybe playing for the B&G makes the IT factor to bloom for him. The kid is really happy and proud to play for the Steelers
 
I think that if swagger and a sense of self-importance made a QB any better, Ryan Leaf and Jamarcus Russell would have been All-Pros.
Do you know who i heard tons of talk about having the “it” factor? Baker ******* Mayfield, who, if we are talking about making commercials, id totally agree… qb’ing… meh not so much
 
We’ll see… the beauty of football is its play on the grass not on paper… there is good reason to believe Mitch could be a steal. The big knock on him was lack of playing time in college his college team went to a running offense and he had a good qb in front of him. But he got valuable playing time with the bears in a harsh media market. I think he held up better than the coach did. but he never really sold himself to the Chicago media which is responsible for the bears never sticking with a qb letting him develop they run em right out of town. I just hope the Steelers dont draft a qb in the first or second… give him a chance, go all in on the guy who wins the qb competition and if they stink it up, go back to the drawing board but this drafting a guy in waiting just suks. Taking a qb in this draft will just be a waste if he’s not good enough to step in day one like Ben did.
Except his own coach contradicts what you just said here. It’s quoted above. Trubisky was better, but the players were more willing to follow another guy.

Remember when we played Peyton Manning in 2005 Playoffs and he waved the punt unit off the field to go for it on 4th down. He directly contradicted Dungy’s call & they converted.

Dan Marino told Jackie Sherrill they were going to end zone in Sugar Bowl win on 4th & called the play he wanted.

It doesn’t have to come in telling coach different:

Montana calming the 49ers huddle in Super Bowl “There’s John Candy” — showed pressure wasn’t getting to him. They followed.

Trubisky gonna have to show it by doing it with trial by fire. And if you f@ck up, don’t care. Bring it again. That seems to be what he’s been missing
 
Do you know who i heard tons of talk about having the “it” factor? Baker ******* Mayfield, who, if we are talking about making commercials, id totally agree… qb’ing… meh not so much
I’m not sure about who you’re talking to, but outside of Skip Bayless, I’ve never heard of anyone saying Mayfield hat the “it” factor.

Confidence, sure. Then again, Bubby had confidence.

Can’t have the “it” factor without the talent.
 
I’m not sure about who you’re talking to, but outside of Skip Bayless, I’ve never heard of anyone saying Mayfield hat the “it” factor.

Confidence, sure. Then again, Bubby had confidence.

Can’t have the “it” factor without the talent.
I was speaking of scouting reports when he was coming out… try typing in “ “baker Mayfield”, “it factor”, “Scouting report” into a search and read them… hell if I remember correctly PFF basically called him the greatest qb ever … that dude was chronically overrated based off of charisma and college system…

The only it factor for me is “can a qb bring a team back late in the game…” other than that the rest of the stuff they chalk up to that is just fantasy bullcrap built off of joe nameth’s legend…
 
Oh he has the "IT" factor alright just put a "SH" right next to IT. He's Garbage! I know some people think he got a RAW deal in Chicago but the bottom like is he's not a very good QB at all. Very poor vision, poor decision making and terrible throws. Just go watch his footage in Chicago....there is nothing that gets me exited watching his play. Everyone points to his play in Week 2 of the Preseason this past year vs the Bears saying he lit it up. He was 20 for 28 with a couple throws that should have been INT's if the starters were playing they would have been INT's. What bothers me more than anything is the errant throws that aren't even close to the intended receiver where he overthrows them by 5 yards or more. I really hope the Steelers are still focused on a QB in the draft because right now the Steelers have arguably the worst QB Trio in the NFL. I'd like to see them draft Kenny Pickett!
 
Trubisky definitely doesn't have the "it" factor. It doesn't take long to see this in a player and we haven't seen it from Mitch. I do believe he is good enough to take a team to the playoffs when he's at his best.
 
All I can say is I hope so. Hell I hope every single one of them plays like a hall of famer. That means they'd win a lot of championships.

Nothing better than being the last man standing on top of the hill.
 
Oh he has the "IT" factor alright just put a "SH" right next to IT. He's Garbage! I know some people think he got a RAW deal in Chicago but the bottom like is he's not a very good QB at all. Very poor vision, poor decision making and terrible throws. Just go watch his footage in Chicago....there is nothing that gets me exited watching his play. Everyone points to his play in Week 2 of the Preseason this past year vs the Bears saying he lit it up. He was 20 for 28 with a couple throws that should have been INT's if the starters were playing they would have been INT's. What bothers me more than anything is the errant throws that aren't even close to the intended receiver where he overthrows them by 5 yards or more. I really hope the Steelers are still focused on a QB in the draft because right now the Steelers have arguably the worst QB Trio in the NFL. I'd like to see them draft Kenny Pickett!
Pickett's going top 10 to the Panthers at number 6. That pick at No. 6 is the only pick the Panthers have until the 4th round. So, they either use it or try to trade back for more picks. With all the interest they showed in Pickett at Pitt's pro day (HC, GM, OC and QB coach were present), it looks like they're planning on using it. Also, factor in that their QBs are Sam Darnold and P.J. Walker .... the writing's on the wall for this one. Unless they trade for Jimmy G or Mayfield.
 
Except his own coach contradicts what you just said here. It’s quoted above. Trubisky was better, but the players were more willing to follow another guy.

I think one example shows that is not always the case. Trubisky signed with the Steelers and later a very talented RG, with a lot of other options, signed with the Steelers, following Trubisky to Pittsburgh.
 
All I can say is I hope so. Hell I hope every single one of them plays like a hall of famer. That means they'd win a lot of championships.

Nothing better than being the last man standing on top of the hill.


Sometimes it's enough to be

"the only LUXURY car in the parking lot"




Salute the nation
 
Hopefully follows the Jim Plunkett trajectory.
So, suck all your career, win a Super Bowl when starter is hurt, suck enough to get benched again and luck into Marcus Allen?
 
He won 2 Super Bowls , don't care about the how's care about the how manys. We win 2 Super Bowls with Trubisky I think everyone would be thrilled .
 
Yeah, Plunkett actually had 8 touchdowns and 25 INTs in his second season. Yikes. 164 TDs and 198 interceptions in his career. Other than winning those two Super Bowls (and he did play well in those games), there's not really much there to aspire.
 
Top