• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Greatest Steeler Defensive Back EVER

CoolieMan

Most Intelligent Poster
Moderator
Forefather
Joined
Apr 9, 2014
Messages
19,086
Reaction score
35,078
Points
113
Location
Heaven on Earth
So in any sane person's mind it should come down to three guys

Mel Blount
Rod Woodson
Troy Polamalu

so who is the greatest.....and who fills out the top 5

Ike?Shell? Carnell Lake, Jake Butler (for the old guys), Myres? (well it may be a few years until he is in the discussion)

for the record my top 5

Blount (they changed the rules because of him)
Woodson
Polamalu
Shell
Taylor
 
1. Mel Blount,- Easy answer for me.
2. Jack Butler
3. Donnie Shell,
4 Troy Polamalu
5 Rod Woodson,
6 Dwayne Woodruff
7 Mike Wagner
 
To me, it is hard to choose between Blount and Woodson for number one. If Woodson could have put his hands on receivers like Blount could for the first half of his career, there might not be a question, as Woodson was the superior playmaker, IMO.

I'd go...

1) Woodson
2) Blount
3) Polamalu
4) Lake
5) Shell

I give Lake the edge over Shell due to his versatility. He saved two Steelers seasons (1995 and 1997) by moving from safety to corner and playing at an extremely high level both times
 
To me, it is hard to choose between Blount and Woodson for number one. If Woodson could have put his hands on receivers like Blount could for the first half of his career, there might not be a question, as Woodson was the superior playmaker, IMO.

I'd go...

1) Woodson
2) Blount
3) Polamalu
4) Lake
5) Shell

I give Lake the edge over Shell due to his versatility. He saved two Steelers seasons (1995 and 1997) by moving from safety to corner and playing at an extremely high level both times

For me I look at longevity (stood the test of time), total INTs and then there is the matter of Blount not Woodson who had the game changed because of his play. Not to mention Rod flew the coop , for me he dropped a few for not being s Steeler for life. Something he had the opportunity to do, but passed.
 
 
Never saw Jack Butler play , so tough to rank

Rod Woodson 1A Mel Blount 1B
Troy
Shell
Lake
honourable mention Ryan Clark and Ike Taylor
 
For me I look at longevity (stood the test of time), total INTs and then there is the matter of Blount not Woodson who had the game changed because of his play. Not to mention Rod flew the coop , for me he dropped a few for not being s Steeler for life. Something he had the opportunity to do, but passed.

This is going to be an interesting thread.

My picks:

1. Blount
2. Polamalu
3. Woodson
4. Shell
5. Big PLAY Willie Gay




I realize no one is giving LAKE anything but I think he deserves the sportsmanship VOTE for as unselfish at changing PRO-BOWL position to accommodate the team those two seasons.

Other than that the list(s) are pretty solid.




Salute the nation
 
I realize no one is giving LAKE anything but I think he deserves the sportsmanship VOTE for as unselfish at changing PRO-BOWL position to accommodate the team those two seasons.

Other than that the list(s) are pretty solid.




Salute the nation

I loved how Lake actually had to temporarily play a harder position and excel at it.
 
He was as good or better than Blount at the corner position. IDC if he left the Steelers over a contract.

Based on?

games played -no
career INT's -no
single season INT's - no 11 compared to 8.
Harder hitter? no
Caused rule change -Blount

Your honor defense rests.
 
Last edited:
So we just asked Hall-of-Fame cornerback Rod Woodson on the latest Talk of Fame Network broadcast to name his top cornerback … ever … and, sorry, Brandon, but Darrelle Revis didn't make the cut. Mel Blount, star cornerback on Pittsburgh’s Steel Curtain defense of the 1970s, did.

“Mel Blount, to me, is the best corner to ever play in the National Football League,” said Woodson, now an assistant coach with the Oakland Raiders. “If you ever met Mel, first of all, he’s a huge corner. He’s 6-4-ish. He wears these huge cowboy boots, this 10-gallon hat (and) this huge belt buckle. But he’s just so long and so fast and so fluid as an athlete.


“He was before his time. And when they make a rule up because you’re just destroying receivers down the field you’re doing something right. So putting that five-year chuck rule in there was really for Mel Blount because he was dismantling receivers down the field.”


A tall, fast and physical corner, Blount was so effective with his aggressive "bump-and-run" coverage that the NFL enacted a rule midway through his career to make physical play downfield illegal -- a change that became known as "the Mel Blount Rule."

But that didn't deter Blount. He not only was an all-decade choice who played on four Super Bowl winners; he was a six-time All Pro named to the NFL’s 75th anniversary team and chosen the NFL’s Most Valuable Defensive Player in 1975 when he led the league with 11 interceptions.

Like Woodson, who followed him to the Steelers in 1987, Blount was used as a kickoff returner early in his career. Unlike Woodson, he never was moved to safety and played with only one franchise, the Steelers, where his number 47 jersey is no longer issued.

“I just think he could’ve played in any era,” said Woodson. “And if you think now, everybody’s trying to find a Mel Blount in 2016. So what he had and what he was … way back then … was before his time.”

Rod even picked Mel Blount

:towel:
 
Top