• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Why Diontae Johnson Doesn’t Have a ‘Drop Problem’

Steeler Nation

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
2,542
Reaction score
4,985
Points
93
When it comes to professional sports in the city of Pittsburgh, the fans are as passionate as they come. The Terrible Towel is a known staple not only to football fans, but sports fans across the world. People from all over pay attention, cheer for, and against the team in black and gold. On any given Sunday in the fall, fans in the city of Pittsburgh will conjugate at their homes, the local watering hole or Heinz Field to cheer on their beloved Pittsburgh Steelers.

When it comes to playing for the black and gold, it comes with a an expectation that the athlete will be under a level of scrutiny for any mistake made on the field. No one has been subject to this treatment more than Diontae Johnson. He has been booed and critiqued by many Steelers fans over his first three years in Pittsburgh. After looking deeper into his stats, it was quite surprising to see how he compared to other ‘big name’ receivers in the game and it raised the question “why is he so criticized?”






In 2019, the Steelers went into the season without a true number one receiver. After the departure of Antonio Brown, they expected JuJu Smith-Schuster to take over the lead role but quickly saw a decline in his numbers without the Pro Bowl receiver playing on the other side of him. After the lack of production from JuJu, they started turning to rookie receiver Diontae Johsnon for answers. By the end of the season, Johnson was seeing close to 80% of the snaps and roughly 10 targets per game.

2020 for Johnson did not go as expected. The receiver had high hopes from Steelers fans. He did end up with over 900 yards receiving and 7 touchdowns, but that didn’t come without the cost of a league leading 13 drops. The criticism was swirling and fans were calling for him to be benched.

The 2021 season was a night and day difference. Johnson had over 1,100 yards receiving, with 107 targets and 8 touchdowns. All of this was done while only recording 7 drops (including the postseason), yet Johnson was still called out by Steelers fans to be benched. Sure, all of Johnson’s 7 drops occurred in the last 6 games, but after comparing Johnson’s stats to other star receivers, it appears his drop problem isn’t as significant as people think.






Johnson, when compared to other receivers such as Keenan Allen, Deebo Samuel, and D.J Moore had less drops and a similar amount of targets. Johnson also had more touchdowns than all three, yet they didn’t face as much criticism and Johnson did. Also, Johnson had touchdowns in key moments in wins against the Buffalo Bills and Baltimore Ravens.

So, Steelers fans can give Diontae a break and be thankful that they do indeed have a true number one receiver on the offense. And if the rumors that have been reported are true about Johnson wanting $15 million per year for his next contract, the Steelers must sign him long-term and lock up Johnson for years to come.



What do you think of Diontae Johnson so far? Leave a comment in the comment section below!

#SteelerNation

Support SteelerNation by clicking here to read the story..
 
Also you have to look at when the drops happen. Are they a drop on first and 10 when you have a lead or is it a 3rd and 2 when your trailing trying to make a comeback. How you handle pressure and play thru the game is a big part of it. To me this guy is just not the guy that relishes pressure and never takes a play off. As i have said many times with this guy it seems he takes a lot of snaps off or quits on plays early.
 
hes a #2 man and we already got #2s trade him trade, trade up or get picks for next year.
 
PFF is predicting he will get $17 million per. I think that is way too much. I don't even like him at $15 but we will probably have to pay that to keep him. I'm thinking more like $12 or $13 million should be more than adequate for what he is. Has he even seen much, if any, double coverage? A true number 1 sees double coverage a good bit and can still beat it.
 
Trade him whole he still has “potential“
 
we have been spoiled by Ward and AB to have WRs that win the challenged catches. I think that's what we most criticize of both him and Claypool
Ward had some drops too… even in the clutch… yes he was great, but everyone has drops… heck he once dropped a pass and inadvertently kicked it into the air for an interception… still was a great wr…
 
I just feel the need again to point out he had pretty much the same stats as Hill or Diggs i think he fell 80 yards short of hill and 60 from diggs in one fewer game… i mean he was top 5 in catches and top 10 in yards… tied for 16th in tds… really good yac too.. i don’t know how people don’t think he is worth number one money… he isnt AB but AB was the best of his era… not likely to find that again anytime soon
 
He's worth No. 1 money but I don't see him anywhere near being a top 10 WR in the league. I even have a hard time saying he is a top 20 WR in the game. I would look to pay him in the 20-25 slot if possible - whatever that is. If he wants top 10 money, then let him walk as he definitely hasn't proven to be that good. I could easily pick 10 WR's probably off the top of my head that I would take over him.
 
PFF is predicting he will get $17 million per. I think that is way too much. I don't even like him at $15 but we will probably have to pay that to keep him. I'm thinking more like $12 or $13 million should be more than adequate for what he is. Has he even seen much, if any, double coverage? A true number 1 sees double coverage a good bit and can still beat it.


Good numbers, I was at 14 mil - 4 years last two easy cut.



Salute the nation
 
All of this was done while only recording 7 drops (including the postseason), yet Johnson was still called out by Steelers fans to be benched. Sure, all of Johnson’s 7 drops occurred in the last 6 games ...

Dn95ULeU0AAdM0N.jpg
 
A ton of his catches are on bubble screens and short passes. He does not really run a complete route tree and is not clutch. He has incredible quickness and is elusive as hell but no way is he worth 15 million a year. Quite the conundrum as the Steelers really have a weak WR corps with few options.
 
You guys have no idea what a #1 receiver is. It's the guy that gets the most targets and receptions on the team.

DJ is that guy and plays the X where all our top targets always go. AB, Ward, Holmes, Yancy, Stallworth all Xs

And our X just made the Pro Bowl and some of you aren't happy? Give me one of the best receivers in the league at getting open quickly (#1 by PFF stats for getting open on the break), and I will build a team around that guy. Remember how good we were at passing in the first Cincy game when he didn't play? Worst offensive game of the year.

Also BTW, he's light years beyond the production of Ward, AB, Yancy, and Stallworth in their first 3 years and is the only WR to make the Pro Bowl in their first 3 seasons as a WR. (AB did it as a returner in year 2)

A lot of Steeler fans want to throw the baby out with the bathwater here...
 
You guys have no idea what a #1 receiver is. It's the guy that gets the most targets and receptions on the team.

DJ is that guy and plays the X where all our top targets always go. AB, Ward, Holmes, Yancy, Stallworth all Xs

And our X just made the Pro Bowl and some of you aren't happy? Give me one of the best receivers in the league at getting open quickly (#1 by PFF stats for getting open on the break), and I will build a team around that guy. Remember how good we were at passing in the first Cincy game when he didn't play? Worst offensive game of the year.

Also BTW, he's light years beyond the production of Ward, AB, Yancy, and Stallworth in their first 3 years and is the only WR to make the Pro Bowl in their first 3 seasons as a WR. (AB did it as a returner in year 2)

A lot of Steeler fans want to throw the baby out with the bathwater here...
DJ does run backwards a lot though
 
You guys have no idea what a #1 receiver is. It's the guy that gets the most targets and receptions on the team.

DJ is that guy and plays the X where all our top targets always go. AB, Ward, Holmes, Yancy, Stallworth all Xs

And our X just made the Pro Bowl and some of you aren't happy? Give me one of the best receivers in the league at getting open quickly (#1 by PFF stats for getting open on the break), and I will build a team around that guy. Remember how good we were at passing in the first Cincy game when he didn't play? Worst offensive game of the year.

Also BTW, he's light years beyond the production of Ward, AB, Yancy, and Stallworth in their first 3 years and is the only WR to make the Pro Bowl in their first 3 seasons as a WR. (AB did it as a returner in year 2)

A lot of Steeler fans want to throw the baby out with the bathwater here...
Just because he is the best on the team doesn’t make him a #1 WR, who deserves #1 money. I would give him top 20 money with reasonable incentives that would allow for him to earn top dollar.
 
Just because he is the best on the team doesn’t make him a #1 WR, who deserves #1 money. I would give him top 20 money with reasonable incentives that would allow for him to earn top dollar.
What part of making a Pro Bowl, being #5 in the NFL in receptions, and #10 in yards don't make him a #1 WR?

Our Xs don't start producing until year 4, and he's been producing since year 1. Look at AB, Ward, Stallworth, and Holmes. None of their stats in the first 3 years even touch DJs. He's the best WR we've ever had starting out as an X. And he's gotten better each year.

$15M will be a steal to lock him up after next season. See AB's 2nd contract.
 
As I've said, DJ is a WR1 on our team but he is definitely not one of the top 10 (out of 32 WR1's from all teams). I don't even know if he is in the top 20. I would like to pay him in the 20 to 25 range but we will probably have to get closer to 15. I certainly wouldn't pay him any higher than that. DJ would (or at least should) never be tagged right now. He is not worth that. Rumor is/was he said he would take $15 million per. I would offer $13 or whatever that 20-25 range out of the top 32 WR's out there. Slot him there to start but still don't sniff the top 10. No way in hell he is worth top 10 WR money.
 
DJ does run backwards a lot though
That's the thing that drives me crazy but something the coaches should be able to correct. He often goes backwards after catching the ball in an effort to avoid (circle back around) the defender and break out for the big gain. Admirable effort but often loses yards and foolish on borderline first down receptions.
 
We will see how much they thing of DJ if they go wide out or not on Day one...

I think if one they like falls to them in second....they will jump on it...
 
That's the thing that drives me crazy but something the coaches should be able to correct. He often goes backwards after catching the ball in an effort to avoid (circle back around) the defender and break out for the big gain. Admirable effort but often loses yards and foolish on borderline first down receptions.
It’s a recurring problem. The guy has speed, has great route running and cuts. But once he catches he runs backwards
 
What part of making a Pro Bowl, being #5 in the NFL in receptions, and #10 in yards don't make him a #1 WR?

Our Xs don't start producing until year 4, and he's been producing since year 1. Look at AB, Ward, Stallworth, and Holmes. None of their stats in the first 3 years even touch DJs. He's the best WR we've ever had starting out as an X. And he's gotten better each year.

$15M will be a steal to lock him up after next season. See AB's 2nd contract.
Pro Bowl is a popularity contest, nothing more, and he only made that because others ahead of him declined. When he makes All-Pro, then we can count it as a first.

you think he deserves 15 million a year, hell I would offer him 20 million, with a million reduction for every drop.
 
Top