• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

2024 draft simulator.

20.
Taliese Fuaga OT Oregon State
51.
Payton Wilson LB NC State
84.
Mike Sainristil CB Michigan
98.
Johnny Wilson WR Florida State
119.
Hunter Nourzad OC Penn State
178.
Logan Lee DT Iowa
195.
Isaac Guerendo RB Louisville
 
Not my final mock; but this haul is pretty darn good...

team-logo
PIT
sk-logo

20.
NFL-team-logo

JC LathamOT Alabama - I'm still valuing OT over OC and JC will put Dan Moore Jr. on the bench. Where he belongs...
51.
NFL-team-logo

Keon ColemanWR Florida State - Is he a WR or TE? I don't care about his 40 time - the kid can be WR2 by mid-season.
84.
NFL-team-logo

Zach FrazierOC West Virginia - Glory, glory, hallelujah. Nothing else needs to be said.
98.
NFL-team-logo

Xavier LegetteWR South Carolina - I see a lot of Juju in Xavier's game. Plus we need more talent in the slot...
119.
NFL-team-logo

Braden FiskeDT Florida State - I like this kid's game. Interior biggie w/ a super-duty motor!!!
178.
NFL-team-logo

Max MeltonCB Rutgers - I think Trice comes back and plays better than expected. Melton is insurance.
195.
NFL-team-logo

Kamren KinchensS Miami (FL) - Need young depth.
 
Not my final mock; but this haul is pretty darn good...

team-logo
PIT
sk-logo

20.
NFL-team-logo

JC LathamOT Alabama - I'm still valuing OT over OC and JC will put Dan Moore Jr. on the bench. Where he belongs...
51.
NFL-team-logo

Keon ColemanWR Florida State - Is he a WR or TE? I don't care about his 40 time - the kid can be WR2 by mid-season.
84.
NFL-team-logo

Zach FrazierOC West Virginia - Glory, glory, hallelujah. Nothing else needs to be said.
98.
NFL-team-logo

Xavier LegetteWR South Carolina - I see a lot of Juju in Xavier's game. Plus we need more talent in the slot...
119.
NFL-team-logo

Braden FiskeDT Florida State - I like this kid's game. Interior biggie w/ a super-duty motor!!!
178.
NFL-team-logo

Max MeltonCB Rutgers - I think Trice comes back and plays better than expected. Melton is insurance.
195.
NFL-team-logo

Kamren KinchensS Miami (FL) - Need young depth.
Not a fan of TWO WRs before adding much needed depth on DL.
 
Not my final mock; but this haul is pretty darn good...

team-logo
PIT
sk-logo

20.
NFL-team-logo

JC LathamOT Alabama - I'm still valuing OT over OC and JC will put Dan Moore Jr. on the bench. Where he belongs...
51.
NFL-team-logo

Keon ColemanWR Florida State - Is he a WR or TE? I don't care about his 40 time - the kid can be WR2 by mid-season.
84.
NFL-team-logo

Zach FrazierOC West Virginia - Glory, glory, hallelujah. Nothing else needs to be said.
98.
NFL-team-logo

Xavier LegetteWR South Carolina - I see a lot of Juju in Xavier's game. Plus we need more talent in the slot...
119.
NFL-team-logo

Braden FiskeDT Florida State - I like this kid's game. Interior biggie w/ a super-duty motor!!!
178.
NFL-team-logo

Max MeltonCB Rutgers - I think Trice comes back and plays better than expected. Melton is insurance.
195.
NFL-team-logo

Kamren KinchensS Miami (FL) - Need young depth.
only one alabama player????

doubt Frazier is there at 84
 
  • 20
    Nate Wiggins
    CB | Clemson
    A
  • 51
    Zach Frazier
    IOL | West Virginia
    A+
  • 84
    Calen Bullock
    S | USC
    A
  • 99
    Jermaine Burton
    WR | Alabama
    A+
  • 119
    Jeremiah Trotter Jr.
    LB | Clemson
    A+
  • 154
    Javon Foster
    OT | Missouri
    A+
  • 155
    Nelson Ceaser
    EDGE | Houston
    A
  • 178
    Luke McCaffrey
    WR | Rice
    B+
  • 195
    Edefuan Ulofoshio
    LB | Washington
    B+
  • 213
    Khristian Boyd
    DL | Northern Iowa
    A+
  • 254
    Daijun Edwards
    RB | Georgia
    A+
 
Not my final mock; but this haul is pretty darn good...

team-logo
PIT
sk-logo

20.
NFL-team-logo

JC LathamOT Alabama - I'm still valuing OT over OC and JC will put Dan Moore Jr. on the bench. Where he belongs...
51.
NFL-team-logo

Keon ColemanWR Florida State - Is he a WR or TE? I don't care about his 40 time - the kid can be WR2 by mid-season.
84.
NFL-team-logo

Zach FrazierOC West Virginia - Glory, glory, hallelujah. Nothing else needs to be said.
98.
NFL-team-logo

Xavier LegetteWR South Carolina - I see a lot of Juju in Xavier's game. Plus we need more talent in the slot...
119.
NFL-team-logo

Braden FiskeDT Florida State - I like this kid's game. Interior biggie w/ a super-duty motor!!!
178.
NFL-team-logo

Max MeltonCB Rutgers - I think Trice comes back and plays better than expected. Melton is insurance.
195.
NFL-team-logo

Kamren KinchensS Miami (FL) - Need young depth.
I'd be stoked IF this happened. Very rare to get lucky in the "draw" like this. I do think Melton will be had late BUT Fiske @ #119, WOW!
 
Not a fan of TWO WRs before adding much needed depth on DL.
I have to ask why?

George Pickens is a ? as WR1 and then there's absolutely nothing behind him. The Steelers are returning their starting 3 DL from last season with Heyward, Ogunjobi, and Benton and have Leal, Adams, Loudermilk, and now Lowry as experienced depth.
 
Not my final mock; but this haul is pretty darn good...

team-logo
PIT
sk-logo

20.
NFL-team-logo

JC LathamOT Alabama - I'm still valuing OT over OC and JC will put Dan Moore Jr. on the bench. Where he belongs...
51.
NFL-team-logo

Keon ColemanWR Florida State - Is he a WR or TE? I don't care about his 40 time - the kid can be WR2 by mid-season.
84.
NFL-team-logo

Zach FrazierOC West Virginia - Glory, glory, hallelujah. Nothing else needs to be said.
98.
NFL-team-logo

Xavier LegetteWR South Carolina - I see a lot of Juju in Xavier's game. Plus we need more talent in the slot...
119.
NFL-team-logo

Braden FiskeDT Florida State - I like this kid's game. Interior biggie w/ a super-duty motor!!!
178.
NFL-team-logo

Max MeltonCB Rutgers - I think Trice comes back and plays better than expected. Melton is insurance.
195.
NFL-team-logo

Kamren KinchensS Miami (FL) - Need young depth.
Hey Berm…….knowing that you watch all the ‘Bama games,your honest opinion/scouting of Jermaine Burton. Many of us have him penciled in 3rd round.
 
I have to ask why?

George Pickens is a ? as WR1 and then there's absolutely nothing behind him. The Steelers are returning their starting 3 DL from last season with Heyward, Ogunjobi, and Benton and have Leal, Adams, Loudermilk, and now Lowry as experienced depth.
Fully agree Steelerfan. Pickens definitely has not even proven himself as a #1 yet. Has the potential to….but not there yet. It’s a huge year for him and his future this season. Let’s see how he handles it. Can you imagine if he gets injured. It would not surprise me at all if they take a WR as a first rounder,depending if there’s one they like there. I believe they will double up too.

Of course Kahn will work some type of trade in for extra pick or player and there will be the usual assortment of players to pick over. So the draft might not be the only route to pickup an extra WR.
 
Fully agree Steelerfan. Pickens definitely has not even proven himself as a #1 yet. Has the potential to….but not there yet. It’s a huge year for him and his future this season. Let’s see how he handles it. Can you imagine if he gets injured. It would not surprise me at all if they take a WR as a first rounder,depending if there’s one they like there. I believe they will double up too.

Of course Kahn will work some type of trade in for extra pick or player and there will be the usual assortment of players to pick over. So the draft might not be the only route to pickup an extra WR.
If the Steelers get Malachi Corley as a slot WR, that will open Pickens to blow the top off of the defense. This kid runs angry and may be the steal of the draft.
 
I have to ask why?

George Pickens is a ? as WR1 and then there's absolutely nothing behind him. The Steelers are returning their starting 3 DL from last season with Heyward, Ogunjobi, and Benton and have Leal, Adams, Loudermilk, and now Lowry as experienced depth.
OK, fair enough question, here is my answer.

1. Cam, 35 years old coming off a serious enough of an injury that it required two surgeries (I believe). His stats (mostly from injury) crapped the bed. At 35 years old, the odds of him all-of-a-sudden performing like a 28 year-old are slim to none. More likely is he will get injured again. (And his cap hit of $22 mill is doing no one favors except for him and his HC who thrives from doing his buddy players favors, such as allowing Cam to keep his salary at his age.) A DT thriving at 35 and hitting a peak performance will virtually be the 1st time in NFL history. Allowing a 35-year-old DT to have a $22 mill cap hit is egregious.

2. Larry O, another older vet with continuing injury history. He's 29 with an arrow pointing downward. In the last 2 years, he's averaging 23 tackles and 2 sacks per season after averaging 35 tackles and 5.5 sacks per year at his peak in 2 years at Cleveland. He's not a "bad" player but he's not a really good player in his prime. His best years are behind him.

3. Benton. A good, promising, young player. We need at least another one.

4. Leal, a tweener without a position. A lot of Steeler fans were enthralled when he was drafted. He hasn't turned out to be that good of a player, sorry to say. Another Colbert/Tomlin miss on draft day.

5. Adams, a decent back up, we need starters.

6. Loudermilk, maybe an OK backup, not even sure about that.

A NT is the most crucial player on a 3-4 D, Tomlin has never learned that. That is the reality of the situation. We need DL help more than one 5th rounder. We will draft one WR early unless we make a trade beforehand. But 2 WRs before bothering to address the DL? Not prudent.
 
Hey Berm…….knowing that you watch all the ‘Bama games,your honest opinion/scouting of Jermaine Burton. Many of us have him penciled in 3rd round.



IMO, he's talented but also can be a tempermental head case. i'd pass on him.
 
Team has a decent history with WRs with issues. We still have players wanting out. That is about as recent as it gets so no thank you on WRs that come with character question marks.
 
Team has a decent history with WRs with issues. We still have players wanting out. That is about as recent as it gets so no thank you on WRs that come with character question marks.
other than Pickens - and i'm of no opinion on his demeanor/character at this point - we have WRs on roster who aren't me-first.
 
other than Pickens - and i'm of no opinion on his demeanor/character at this point - we have WRs on roster who aren't me-first.
Other than Pickens we have a barn (that we didn’t paint with a broad brush) full of not good enough. Their character question marks seem non existent but we can say that about their play on the field too. I was referencing DJ that was just shipped off. Plenty of problems before him too.

They need to bring in strong character football types. Avoid mistakes of the past by not repeating them moving forward.
 
Other than Pickens we have a barn (that we didn’t paint with a broad brush) full of not good enough. Their character question marks seem non existent but we can say that about their play on the field too. I was referencing DJ that was just shipped off. Plenty of problems before him too.

They need to bring in strong character football types. Avoid mistakes of the past by not repeating them moving forward.
my dark horse we take in the draft is Brian Thomas.
Pickens - Thomas - CA3 and Jefferson/Mims/etc as the 4 would be a nice little group.
 
changing it up a little...

27.
Adonai MitchellWR Texas

51.
Ruke OrhorhoroDT Clemson

71.
Cole BishopS Utah

84.
D.J. JamesCB Auburn

98.
James WilliamsLB Miami (FL)

119.
Matt GoncalvesOT Pittsburgh

178.
Hunter NourzadOC Penn State

195.
Terique OwensWR Missouri State


20.
Troy FautanuOG Washington
51.
Junior ColsonLB Michigan
88.
Xavier LegetteWR South Carolina
98.
Zach FrazierOC West Virginia
120.
Mason SmithDT LSU
126.
Brenden RiceWR USC
195.
Tykee SmithS Georgia
210.
Jordan TravisQB Florida State
 
34.
Graham Barton
OCDuke
trade-icon

51.
Michael Penix Jr.
QBWashington
64.
Roger Rosengarten
OTWashington
trade-icon

84.
Devontez Walker
WRNorth Carolina
87.
Maason Smith
DTLSU
trade-icon

98.
Josh Newton
CBTCU
103.
Johnny Wilson
WRFlorida State
trade-icon

119.
Jared Wiley
TETCU
 
OK, fair enough question, here is my answer.

1. Cam, 35 years old coming off a serious enough of an injury that it required two surgeries (I believe). His stats (mostly from injury) crapped the bed. At 35 years old, the odds of him all-of-a-sudden performing like a 28 year-old are slim to none. More likely is he will get injured again. (And his cap hit of $22 mill is doing no one favors except for him and his HC who thrives from doing his buddy players favors, such as allowing Cam to keep his salary at his age.) A DT thriving at 35 and hitting a peak performance will virtually be the 1st time in NFL history. Allowing a 35-year-old DT to have a $22 mill cap hit is egregious.

2. Larry O, another older vet with continuing injury history. He's 29 with an arrow pointing downward. In the last 2 years, he's averaging 23 tackles and 2 sacks per season after averaging 35 tackles and 5.5 sacks per year at his peak in 2 years at Cleveland. He's not a "bad" player but he's not a really good player in his prime. His best years are behind him.

3. Benton. A good, promising, young player. We need at least another one.

4. Leal, a tweener without a position. A lot of Steeler fans were enthralled when he was drafted. He hasn't turned out to be that good of a player, sorry to say. Another Colbert/Tomlin miss on draft day.

5. Adams, a decent back up, we need starters.

6. Loudermilk, maybe an OK backup, not even sure about that.

A NT is the most crucial player on a 3-4 D, Tomlin has never learned that. That is the reality of the situation. We need DL help more than one 5th rounder. We will draft one WR early unless we make a trade beforehand. But 2 WRs before bothering to address the DL? Not prudent.
All fair points, but if we were talking Benton and then a guy like Leal, Loudermilk, and a scrub off the streets as the top 4, then I'd be more concerned. The Steelers have a high-end WR2 and a bunch of guys who wouldn't crack the top 4 for most teams.
 
All fair points, but if we were talking Benton and then a guy like Leal, Loudermilk, and a scrub off the streets as the top 4, then I'd be more concerned. The Steelers have a high-end WR2 and a bunch of guys who wouldn't crack the top 4 for most teams.
Not disagreeing, WR needs help bad, but not 2 WR picks before the DL even gets 1 draft pick. Our starting DL has a 35-year-old and a guy turning 30. Both players are suffering from recent injuries. Then we got one young, promising player. The only other 3 DLmen are unlikely starting material. We NEED another young promising player.
 
Not disagreeing, WR needs help bad, but not 2 WR picks before the DL even gets 1 draft pick. Our starting DL has a 35-year-old and a guy turning 30. Both players are suffering from recent injuries. Then we got one young, promising player. The only other 3 DLmen are unlikely starting material. We NEED another young promising player.
You are debating aging vs a position that doesn’t have a second and third option. They cleared the pantry. I get the aging is a concern but they brought in a vet and resigned a NT. A QB can’t throw to himself. They need multiple players.
 
You are debating aging vs a position that doesn’t have a second and third option. They cleared the pantry. I get the aging is a concern but they brought in a vet and resigned a NT. A QB can’t throw to himself. They need multiple players.
No denying we need multiple players at WR, but that doesn't preclude taking 2 WRs before drafting even 1 DL. But this is a Shades' team, which so far means not prioritizing the lines enough - a major faulty plan, and he's been doing it for over a decade.
 
Top