The writer has a decent reputation for not being a hack. I think he knows he wrote a piece of crap though because he's refusing all interview requests. He's in hiding. I think his bosses at SI came up with the headline and told him to go dig up some dirt. He came back to them and said "I got nothing." So they just recycled a bunch of old crap because they were committed to running the story and getting the clicks / attention you get by taking shots at someone of Big Ben's stature.