Eli must wait

[stuntmanmike]

Eli didn’t just play good in big games he dominated! Eli played hero ball every little kid growing up dreaming dreams of being a hero winning the big games has dreamt of being like Eli… they don’t dream about leading the league 10 times! But… ya if they kept Ken stabler out till after he was dead, have kept LC out they are capable of anything.

 

[DocScott]

Eli won two Super Bowls for the Giants but just the same, Phil Simms did too and he's not in the HOF. Ben gets in, 1st year eligible, FACTS!!!!

 

[Steelmann]

Eli won two Super Bowls for the Giants but just the same, Phil Simms did too and he's not in the HOF. Ben gets in, 1st year eligible, FACTS!!!!

Phil Simms did not win 2 Super Bowls. He had a MVP in a great performance against Denver in his only appearance.
He got injured before the playoffs began when the giants won against Buffalo. Jeff Hostetler was the winning QB that took over.

Edit……of course that means he has 2 rings. But certainly not the same thing. At least, from my perspective.