Um. You are forgetting the immaculate reception game. I know the title of the thread is my favorite Steeler game non super bowl so I'll let you youngsters have a pass since it was before your time . But this has to be the first if not the best non super bowl game. It wasn't really what you would call an exciting offensive game but it spotlighted the Steeler defense and was certainly a sign of things to come . And then of course there was the ending. Just goes to show how difficult it is to compare games in different eras.