Steelers 2025 draft needs by Position

[madinsomniac]

1. Qb. With only two on the roster, and needing 4 for camp arms.. even if Arod was a lock, they still must acquire one more either by draft or udfa...
this could mean one or even two picks in this draft, ranging anywhere from 1st round to 7th round, depending which direction they go...

2. DL. Cam Heyward is just old enough that you want the replacement in the pipeline now... its a great DL draft, but you really need the first or third to be one if you want top level talent..

3. RB. Warren is RB1. Gainwell is RB2... but after that its the ancient Patterson... taking a late to mid round flyer here is probably a worthy plan

After the top 3 spots, it gets more hard to see where they need guys... mostly they need injury fill in types...

They could shore up IOL.. they lost Daniels and Herbig there... and you need lots of depth. They have more depth at OT right now, and pure C.. Stephenson is a utility jack of all trades... they probably need abother Guard type in case of injury

They could take a stab at a low round WR. There is no need for a high round one. You need 7 viable ones these days, but you will only carry 5 or 6 on the 53 man roster... there needs to be one or two guys on the PS with potential to fill in well... one of the 53 will be a pure ST guy ( Ben Skowronek) two will be outside guys, (DK and Pickens) two will be slot guys ( CA3 and Wilson) and one will be a utility reserve... which currently is held by Scotty Miller... there isnt a need there, but having another guy who can play outside and probably can be stashed on the ps would be a very nice idea...

It would be hard to see them taking another Tackle or a TE... though maybe very low if a guy really dropped

Inside lb seems cramped as it is, I dont see a move there
outside LB maybe they could take a special teams / development type guy.

There is weird speculation in some places we would use a first on a safety... i dont see it, but another later round pick at the position is a possibility just from a competition vantage point. Also Miles Killabrew is getting close to the expiration date of a special teams ace... he will turn 32 in may... so a Special teans demon might be an add here

At CB the staff seems far more happy with the makeup than the fans... i wouldnt expect a significant add there this year... like Safety, that final DB that plays Special teams could be an add... Piere is really good... but may be a guy they look to replace..
I do think the starters and top backups are already on the team at the various DB spots...

 

[keslerclan]

Imo, we don’t have enough picks to cover our needs:
We have no #1 (with acceptable production) at QB, RB, CB2, LT, RT, and NT/DE2.
1. At QB, we presently have an average back-up (Rudy-3rd rounder) and a below average back-up (S.Thompson-7th). Maybe we will also have a low-mobility geriatric future HOFer. Either way, we need a pick anywhere from the 1st-6th rounds to see if we can find a Diamond in the rough. Then again, we’ve had the #2 overall, the #11 overall and our own #20 overall and none of them performed well in our scheme/style/redundant offense. Maybe it’s not the QB?
2. At RB, we have a RB2 that has injury history on limited carries with a few fumbles and another RB2. Whether we get a speed guy only and just use our RB2s as RB1s and have the speed pick (early/later) as a 3rd-down guy, we have no bell-cow back on the roster and need a pick (3rd-5th) plus a UFA who can be a back-up. We have a scheme based on running the ball. We need to value the position more than most.
3. Who is our CB2? We don’t have anyone with acceptable production on the team. We need to draft an outside CB in 1st-4th rounds in case our inexperienced CB4s cannot cover anyone.
4. At LT&RT…two of the obvious key elements to a play-action/run-first scheme, we have a guy whose played less than a game, and another that has gotten worse since his rookie year playing in a more critical position at LT which he hasn’t played in a few years now. Mind you, with no dependable back-up behind either. Aside from a new OL Coach, this is the most needed position we need to sign/draft. This is a pick that falls between 1st-4th to get anyone worth a damn. If we don’t cover our butts here, we might as well let Skylar be the QB1 because whoever it is will be killed.
5. Lastly, we have what most assume is our biggest need position on the DL. While we suck at stopping the run anymore, we are making things worse with our oldest player being the only one to create interior pressure. It would be “nice” if we could get his eventual replacement in this draft BUT that might mean we lose out on one of the 4 positions of NEED. There is depth at NT that could be had late/UDFA that would be better than Benton/Adams at NT against the run. Actually, they don’t provide pass pressure either so it’s all good.
Might be easier to get a decent run-plugger at NT and try Benton at DE/DT.

Imo, we have so many holes their may not be enough fingers in this draft to keep the boat from sinking.

This doesn’t seem like one draft can fix this ship…maybe that’s exactly what needs to happen to change our philosophy in the FO?

 

[MT~Forged]

The Steelers can’t stop the run because they play a 2DL set a lot of the time.

 

[Litos]

Imo, we don’t have enough picks to cover our needs:
We have no #1 (with acceptable production) at QB, RB, CB2, LT, RT, and NT/DE2.
1. At QB, we presently have an average back-up (Rudy-3rd rounder) and a below average back-up (S.Thompson-7th). Maybe we will also have a low-mobility geriatric future HOFer. Either way, we need a pick anywhere from the 1st-6th rounds to see if we can find a Diamond in the rough. Then again, we’ve had the #2 overall, the #11 overall and our own #20 overall and none of them performed well in our scheme/style/redundant offense. Maybe it’s not the QB?
2. At RB, we have a RB2 that has injury history on limited carries with a few fumbles and another RB2. Whether we get a speed guy only and just use our RB2s as RB1s and have the speed pick (early/later) as a 3rd-down guy, we have no bell-cow back on the roster and need a pick (3rd-5th) plus a UFA who can be a back-up. We have a scheme based on running the ball. We need to value the position more than most.
3. Who is our CB2? We don’t have anyone with acceptable production on the team. We need to draft an outside CB in 1st-4th rounds in case our inexperienced CB4s cannot cover anyone.
4. At LT&RT…two of the obvious key elements to a play-action/run-first scheme, we have a guy whose played less than a game, and another that has gotten worse since his rookie year playing in a more critical position at LT which he hasn’t played in a few years now. Mind you, with no dependable back-up behind either. Aside from a new OL Coach, this is the most needed position we need to sign/draft. This is a pick that falls between 1st-4th to get anyone worth a damn. If we don’t cover our butts here, we might as well let Skylar be the QB1 because whoever it is will be killed.
5. Lastly, we have what most assume is our biggest need position on the DL. While we suck at stopping the run anymore, we are making things worse with our oldest player being the only one to create interior pressure. It would be “nice” if we could get his eventual replacement in this draft BUT that might mean we lose out on one of the 4 positions of NEED. There is depth at NT that could be had late/UDFA that would be better than Benton/Adams at NT against the run. Actually, they don’t provide pass pressure either so it’s all good.
Might be easier to get a decent run-plugger at NT and try Benton at DE/DT.

Imo, we have so many holes their may not be enough fingers in this draft to keep the boat from sinking.

This doesn’t seem like one draft can fix this ship…maybe that’s exactly what needs to happen to change our philosophy in the FO?

Mostly agree except for CB2, the team signed Slay to be #2 and he is a solid FA pick up for one year.

Regarding OTs, the investment was done with two 1st round picks and is time for both to sink or swim and I rather give them the chance right now that we don't have a franchise QB in place. Investing a high pick, again, at tackle right now is a luxury with so many holes in the roster. Bring a developmental guy in the 5th or 6th.

 

[Fiji Mariner]

1. Qb. With only two on the roster, and needing 4 for camp arms.. even if Arod was a lock, they still must acquire one more either by draft or udfa...
this could mean one or even two picks in this draft, ranging anywhere from 1st round to 7th round, depending which direction they go...

2. DL. Cam Heyward is just old enough that you want the replacement in the pipeline now... its a great DL draft, but you really need the first or third to be one if you want top level talent..

3. RB. Warren is RB1. Gainwell is RB2... but after that its the ancient Patterson... taking a late to mid round flyer here is probably a worthy plan

After the top 3 spots, it gets more hard to see where they need guys... mostly they need injury fill in types...

They could shore up IOL.. they lost Daniels and Herbig there... and you need lots of depth. They have more depth at OT right now, and pure C.. Stephenson is a utility jack of all trades... they probably need abother Guard type in case of injury

They could take a stab at a low round WR. There is no need for a high round one. You need 7 viable ones these days, but you will only carry 5 or 6 on the 53 man roster... there needs to be one or two guys on the PS with potential to fill in well... one of the 53 will be a pure ST guy ( Ben Skowronek) two will be outside guys, (DK and Pickens) two will be slot guys ( CA3 and Wilson) and one will be a utility reserve... which currently is held by Scotty Miller... there isnt a need there, but having another guy who can play outside and probably can be stashed on the ps would be a very nice idea...

It would be hard to see them taking another Tackle or a TE... though maybe very low if a guy really dropped

Inside lb seems cramped as it is, I dont see a move there
outside LB maybe they could take a special teams / development type guy.

There is weird speculation in some places we would use a first on a safety... i dont see it, but another later round pick at the position is a possibility just from a competition vantage point. Also Miles Killabrew is getting close to the expiration date of a special teams ace... he will turn 32 in may... so a Special teans demon might be an add here

At CB the staff seems far more happy with the makeup than the fans... i wouldnt expect a significant add there this year... like Safety, that final DB that plays Special teams could be an add... Piere is really good... but may be a guy they look to replace..
I do think the starters and top backups are already on the team at the various DB spots...

Great post!

I could see a couple scenarios play out where we do DL in 4th then again in 6 or 7

If a QB they covet is there in the first and then a premier RB is still available in the third (no trade scenario where we just have our picks) I could see them waiting until the 4th and hope West, Lott or Walker is available and then grab another late like Hemingway, Pegues or Ingram-Dawkins.

It’s an offensive league and in a deep DL class they could risk it and pick a bit later depending how the draft falls to them.

I don’t expect this but not out of the question imo.

I did a mock the other day and Starks was BPA at 21. Fixes the NB position this year and puts the future Safety on the roster. I’ve done about 20 mocks so far and only 1 where we netted a Safety in the first. So agree it’s definitely low probability, but I can see where it could make sense…again depends how the draft falls.

Netted 1) S/NB-Starks 3) RB-Giddens 4) DL-West 5) OG-Dellinger 6) QB-McCord 7) DL-Ingram-Dawkins

I still like the trade back to 26-30 range best and pick up another pick, but ya gotta have a dance partner.

Definitely agree that WR and CB aren’t nearly the need some are making it out to be…fix QB, RB and DL and add a little depth on the LOS and it’s a great draft.

 

[slashsteel]

For me they have to come away with a QB, RB, DT, and a T. Hopefully in the first 4 picks if everything falls right.

 

[Fiji Mariner]

For me they have to come away with a QB, RB, DT, and a T. Hopefully in the first 4 picks if everything falls right.

Looking at those too 30 visits I’m wondering if the Steelers have moved past OL as being an urgent need.

I’m sure they’ll have some priority UDFAs they try to snag but I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if we see a QB, 2 RBs, 2 DL and then that random BPA flyer in the 7th.

Maybe they skip the RB double dip if AS is higher on Patterson than much of SN is. At his price in a RB rich draft I wouldn’t see why they wouldn’t attempt to replace him (maybe the 2nd RB will be a UDFA since some quality guys are sure to not get drafted)

 

[insaniti]

Imo, we don’t have enough picks to cover our needs:
We have no #1 (with acceptable production) at QB, RB, CB2, LT, RT, and NT/DE2.
1. At QB, we presently have an average back-up (Rudy-3rd rounder) and a below average back-up (S.Thompson-7th). Maybe we will also have a low-mobility geriatric future HOFer. Either way, we need a pick anywhere from the 1st-6th rounds to see if we can find a Diamond in the rough. Then again, we’ve had the #2 overall, the #11 overall and our own #20 overall and none of them performed well in our scheme/style/redundant offense. Maybe it’s not the QB?
2. At RB, we have a RB2 that has injury history on limited carries with a few fumbles and another RB2. Whether we get a speed guy only and just use our RB2s as RB1s and have the speed pick (early/later) as a 3rd-down guy, we have no bell-cow back on the roster and need a pick (3rd-5th) plus a UFA who can be a back-up. We have a scheme based on running the ball. We need to value the position more than most.
3. Who is our CB2? We don’t have anyone with acceptable production on the team. We need to draft an outside CB in 1st-4th rounds in case our inexperienced CB4s cannot cover anyone.
4. At LT&RT…two of the obvious key elements to a play-action/run-first scheme, we have a guy whose played less than a game, and another that has gotten worse since his rookie year playing in a more critical position at LT which he hasn’t played in a few years now. Mind you, with no dependable back-up behind either. Aside from a new OL Coach, this is the most needed position we need to sign/draft. This is a pick that falls between 1st-4th to get anyone worth a damn. If we don’t cover our butts here, we might as well let Skylar be the QB1 because whoever it is will be killed.
5. Lastly, we have what most assume is our biggest need position on the DL. While we suck at stopping the run anymore, we are making things worse with our oldest player being the only one to create interior pressure. It would be “nice” if we could get his eventual replacement in this draft BUT that might mean we lose out on one of the 4 positions of NEED. There is depth at NT that could be had late/UDFA that would be better than Benton/Adams at NT against the run. Actually, they don’t provide pass pressure either so it’s all good.
Might be easier to get a decent run-plugger at NT and try Benton at DE/DT.

Imo, we have so many holes their may not be enough fingers in this draft to keep the boat from sinking.

This doesn’t seem like one draft can fix this ship…maybe that’s exactly what needs to happen to change our philosophy in the FO?

RB - I think with who they have brought in for visits, and who they have talked to, they really like Warren in his current role and want to keep him there. I don't think they moved on from Najee in order to let Warren take his spot, I think they moved on from Najee and look to replace him in the draft. You're not bringing in Kaleb Johnson, Omarion Hampton, Ollie Gordon, or DJ Giddens in to be RB2. Those are workhorse backs that you feed 15-20 times a game. Warren EXCELLS in his role as the change of pace, 3rd down guy. He's excellent in space, he's great out of the backfield as a receiver, he's one of, if not THE best blocking RB in the league. RB in round 3-5.

OT - We have our guys, they have faith that Fautanu is their guy at RT and come back from the injury. And they've been wasting Jones since they traded up to get him by playing him out of position. Jones was also dealing with an injury last year, and after the bye week, his play was improving. He will be much better at LT where he belongs, and as mentioned before, you don't spend back to back first round picks on OT and then not play them. I've mocked an OT and OG in every draft I've done for depth, but not for taking over a starting role. And it's always been 5th and 6th round picks. The FO also resigned Calvin Anderson as their swing tackle, and claimed Lecitus Smith off waivers from NE, another OT.

CB - Right now, Slay is penciled in at #2. They are really high on Trice, and they also signed Echols. Not only is this not a need position, I don't see them drafting one at all. They only brough two in for visits, and I think the only way they take one, is if Thomas or Amos slide to the third round. They aren't the only ones that are high on Trice, he has size and speed you can't teach, and if he can get healthy you're talking about two corners in Porter and Trice that almost mirror each other in ability. That's solid, REALLY solid.

DL - Yup, time to start thinking about Cam's replacement. They've talked to, or had meetings with, or visits to Pittsburgh with Nolen, Harmon, and Grant. Those are the first round guys they like, then you have Pegues, Farmer, Alexander, Roberts at DT and Caldwell and Black at NT. They also signed Esezi Otomewo (DT), Daniel Ekuale (NT), and resigned Loudermilk. The depth is there, making it less of a "we HAVE to draft this position in THIS round" types of picks. With this being a deep DL draft, we could get Cam's replacement outside of the first. But our sucking at stopping the run has less to do with WHO we have on the DL and more to do with the scheme we run on the DL. Also getting a legit NT would allow Benton to slide outside, where he really needs to be. We also still have Leal who was starting to come on before the injury. People forget just how raw he was coming out. He wasn't going to be that impact player right away. But he's 6'4" and 290 with all the physical tools you want, and he's only 24.

We really only have two holes on the roster right now, and that's at RB and QB. They quietly filled others in FA. They weren't super splashy signings, but solid depth signings. RB isn't a position that needs a premium pick to land a starting back. The only real question will be what they do at QB, and that's been a mess since Ben retired.

 

[slashsteel]

For me they have to come away with a QB, RB, DT, and a T. Hopefully in the first 4 picks if everything falls right.

Looking at those too 30 visits I’m wondering if the Steelers have moved past OL as being an urgent need.

I hope not as a case can be made that both have decent question marks. Better to not roll the dice that both answers will be desired results.

 

[Drink IRON City]

The Steelers can’t stop the run because they play a 2DL set a lot of the time.

Add ing the part where they finished 6th against the run in ‘24. NOT nearly the colossal ****-up as many believe.

That 299 yards given up against the rats was definately a bad day, but also an even worse game plan. This 299 is in most people’s minds as to the run stopping ability of said unit.

I agree we need DL, big time, but also realize we need a quality DL to replace Cam. If the high-end DL isn’t there then I wouldn’t reach.



Salute the nation

 

[WindyCitySteel]

3. RB. Warren is RB1. Gainwell is RB2... but after that its the ancient Patterson... taking a late to mid round flyer here is probably a worthy plan

That might be the worst RB room in the league and this is a crazy deep class, if they start the season with these two guys as 1 and 2 it’s a massive fail unless they’re trying to tank.

Warren has averaged 115 carries per year, Gainwell 70. They still need an RB1.

 

[WindyCitySteel]

Add ing the part where they finished 6th against the run in ‘24. NOT nearly the colossal ****-up as many believe.

That 299 yards given up against the rats was definately a bad day, but also an even worse game plan. This 299 is in most people’s minds as to the run stopping ability of said unit.

I agree we need DL, big time, but also realize we need a quality DL to replace Cam. If the high-end DL isn’t there then I wouldn’t reach.



Salute the nation

This is correct — they played nickel vs. the Ravens’ heavy set all game, it was a comically bad game plan and they didn’t adjust.

 

[TDX27]

QB1 is the biggest need, but we aren't drafting high enough to not reach in the 1st round.

They should go with DL in the 1st round as their next obvious need.

They should be looking at RB or QB in the 3rd round, depending on which QB's are still on the board. If Milroe or Shough are there in the 3rd, they take him even if it possibly means using a mid-round pick from 2026 to move up.

After that, you look at CB, OL (probably a G as you can find them easier in the later rounds), and even double-dipping at DL. A flyer on a WR may be in the cards as well.

 

[Drink IRON City]

This is correct — they played nickel vs. the Ravens’ heavy set all game, it was a comically bad game plan and they didn’t adjust.

Gee, thanks for your approval............................................



Salute the nation

 

[Superman]

RB - I think with who they have brought in for visits, and who they have talked to, they really like Warren in his current role and want to keep him there. I don't think they moved on from Najee in order to let Warren take his spot, I think they moved on from Najee and look to replace him in the draft. You're not bringing in Kaleb Johnson, Omarion Hampton, Ollie Gordon, or DJ Giddens in to be RB2. Those are workhorse backs that you feed 15-20 times a game. Warren EXCELLS in his role as the change of pace, 3rd down guy. He's excellent in space, he's great out of the backfield as a receiver, he's one of, if not THE best blocking RB in the league. RB in round 3-5.

OT - We have our guys, they have faith that Fautanu is their guy at RT and come back from the injury. And they've been wasting Jones since they traded up to get him by playing him out of position. Jones was also dealing with an injury last year, and after the bye week, his play was improving. He will be much better at LT where he belongs, and as mentioned before, you don't spend back to back first round picks on OT and then not play them. I've mocked an OT and OG in every draft I've done for depth, but not for taking over a starting role. And it's always been 5th and 6th round picks. The FO also resigned Calvin Anderson as their swing tackle, and claimed Lecitus Smith off waivers from NE, another OT.

CB - Right now, Slay is penciled in at #2. They are really high on Trice, and they also signed Echols. Not only is this not a need position, I don't see them drafting one at all. They only brough two in for visits, and I think the only way they take one, is if Thomas or Amos slide to the third round. They aren't the only ones that are high on Trice, he has size and speed you can't teach, and if he can get healthy you're talking about two corners in Porter and Trice that almost mirror each other in ability. That's solid, REALLY solid.

DL - Yup, time to start thinking about Cam's replacement. They've talked to, or had meetings with, or visits to Pittsburgh with Nolen, Harmon, and Grant. Those are the first round guys they like, then you have Pegues, Farmer, Alexander, Roberts at DT and Caldwell and Black at NT. They also signed Esezi Otomewo (DT), Daniel Ekuale (NT), and resigned Loudermilk. The depth is there, making it less of a "we HAVE to draft this position in THIS round" types of picks. With this being a deep DL draft, we could get Cam's replacement outside of the first. But our sucking at stopping the run has less to do with WHO we have on the DL and more to do with the scheme we run on the DL. Also getting a legit NT would allow Benton to slide outside, where he really needs to be. We also still have Leal who was starting to come on before the injury. People forget just how raw he was coming out. He wasn't going to be that impact player right away. But he's 6'4" and 290 with all the physical tools you want, and he's only 24.

We really only have two holes on the roster right now, and that's at RB and QB. They quietly filled others in FA. They weren't super splashy signings, but solid depth signings. RB isn't a position that needs a premium pick to land a starting back. The only real question will be what they do at QB, and that's been a mess since Ben retired.

IMO, there needs to be some analysis over how drafting a QB in the first - Dart or Sanders - and letting them sit a year would be equated to drafting one of the top guys next year - Manning, Leavett, Allar, Iamaleava. Would any of those four be vastly better than Dart or Sanders after redshirting? Granted, you don't take a QB in Round 1 to let them sit a year, but as you pointed out we did fill our roster with depth.

I don't see taking a RB in the 1st as beneficial. But, we've been eerily quiet on that this year. Not even whispers of who we particularly like of the entire bunch. And that's a solid group of RBs. Not spectacular outside of Jeanty, but solid.

WR - Not in the first. Thornton as high as the 4th, but that's really it.

DL - there's so much depth this draft. Nolen has been compared to Aaron Donald and I don't believe you can pass that up. But, then there's Collins, Sanders, Norman-Lott who could all be had later. And, if Leal pans out we have two DL. Which is pretty much what we use anyway.

DB - While we've got depth at CB, what about Safety. Unfortunately, Minkah's getting up there and last season wasn't his best. Do we roll the dice that he rebounds this year, if say Emmanwori is available?

OL - We could just take ANOTHER LT as insurance in case Fautanu doesn't recover. Or even if he does, push him inside with the new Tackle starting at RT. Imagine an OL of Jones - McCormick/Fautanu - Frazier - McCormick/Fautanu - Wyatt Milum, Donovan Jackson or Cameron Williams. That's a mammoth OL who could provide above average protection for any QB and open serious holes for the running game.

All that said, I predict we **** ourselves, package picks and move up to take Sanders.

 

[insaniti]

IMO, there needs to be some analysis over how drafting a QB in the first - Dart or Sanders - and letting them sit a year would be equated to drafting one of the top guys next year - Manning, Leavett, Allar, Iamaleava. Would any of those four be vastly better than Dart or Sanders after redshirting? Granted, you don't take a QB in Round 1 to let them sit a year, but as you pointed out we did fill our roster with depth.

I don't see taking a RB in the 1st as beneficial. But, we've been eerily quiet on that this year. Not even whispers of who we particularly like of the entire bunch. And that's a solid group of RBs. Not spectacular outside of Jeanty, but solid.

WR - Not in the first. Thornton as high as the 4th, but that's really it.

DL - there's so much depth this draft. Nolen has been compared to Aaron Donald and I don't believe you can pass that up. But, then there's Collins, Sanders, Norman-Lott who could all be had later. And, if Leal pans out we have two DL. Which is pretty much what we use anyway.

DB - While we've got depth at CB, what about Safety. Unfortunately, Minkah's getting up there and last season wasn't his best. Do we roll the dice that he rebounds this year, if say Emmanwori is available?

OL - We could just take ANOTHER LT as insurance in case Fautanu doesn't recover. Or even if he does, push him inside with the new Tackle starting at RT. Imagine an OL of Jones - McCormick/Fautanu - Frazier - McCormick/Fautanu - Wyatt Milum, Donovan Jackson or Cameron Williams. That's a mammoth OL who could provide above average protection for any QB and open serious holes for the running game.

All that said, I predict we **** ourselves, package picks and move up to take Sanders.

There are a lot of OT that I like later in the draft that not only can offer immediate depth, but challenge for starting roles or step in if either of our starters falter or get injured. I like Jalen Travis a lot, he's an athlete in the OT position, Jack Nelson has played both tackle spots and even guard. Ajani Cornelius, his rank on some of the draft sites has been slipping, but another athlete with good size and movement. Logan Brown if he can stay healthy, another Fautanu type player.

Same with Guard, I really like Luke Kandra. Something to be said about not giving up a single sack last season. And speaking of not giving up sacks, Marcus Tate, the past two years, zero sacks, and he is HUGE!.

I like to grab safeties in my mocks, either Penn State safety, I really like Xavier Watt, but not having that second round pick takes him off my board. Malachi Moore is your ball hawking deep safety guy, 4th or 5th round guy. Sleeper pick here would be Hunter Wohler, great size to bring down into the box, but isn't going to be the guy you ask to cover TE one on one.

As for the QB position and letting them sit, somehow that has been turned into a bad thing. The biggest argument against it, is losing a year of control. But if learning for a year helps him grow twice as fast once he does become the starter, I don't see that as a problem. Jordan Love, Patrick Mahomes, Aaron Rodgers are all guys that sat first and it benefitted them and the teams that drafted them. It'd be hard to have any type of true analysis to compare drafting Dart or Sanders this year and sitting them compared to drafting one from the bigger class next year. Anything could happen to those coming out next year, including them staying or bombing out.

One thing that I liked while digging in to Sanders was the fact that he's had a different OC every single year, and his production always increased. That is pretty rare. And one thing that is hurting Dart is the one read offense, will he be able to go through progressions. Even the class next year, I don't see that once in a lifetime prospect that you have to go get. Manning has the name, but also all the pressure. He not only has to follow Arch, but both Peyton and Eli. Coming from that family tho, you know he's going to put in the film study and the work to get better.

 

[WindyCitySteel]

Gee, thanks for your approval............................................



Salute the nation

Just delineating the aforementioned scheme issue, maybe next time include more detail. Overall, though, you’re doing a great job, you’re a real up and comer, keep it up, champ!

 

[SteelerFan448]

QB - Very High priority
The QB room is non-existent and there is no even potential long-term answer. While there are no bad contracts, there's also no hope at the position.

RB - High priority
I like Warren as a part of a 1A/1B package. I don't see him as a back who will carry the load, so the Steelers need a back who can share the load.

WR - Medium priority
Wide receiver is a premium position and if Pickens isn't in the long-term plans, find his replacement now. There are a couple of good options in the first depending on how the draft falls. Otherwise, find a WR with upside late.

TE - Low priority
Freiermuth and Washington are fine. There are some good options and I'd consider a TE in the middle rounds if they are the best available player.

OL - Medium priority
Depth was tested last year and the Steelers lack in this area, plus they will probably need a replacement for Seumalo for 2026. I'd take two OL.

DL - Medium priority
I know this is the position in the draft everyone wants, but the Steelers only play 2 on any given down. If they're taking one in the first, they have to expect plus pass rushing ability down the line, don't take a pure run stopper in the first.

EDGE - Medium priority
While there are three good players, I'd always come away with an EDGE defender in the draft. Pass rushers are too valuable to pass up.

LB - Low priority
They have enough guys at this spot.

CB - High priority
They have Porter and a very old Slay. Get another guy with pedigree--even though they don't seem interested.

S - Medium priority
The starters are set, I just wonder how long Minkah will be here and it would be good to have an option in the pipeline.

 

[Fiji Mariner]

For me they have to come away with a QB, RB, DT, and a T. Hopefully in the first 4 picks if everything falls right.

I hope not as a case can be made that both have decent question marks. Better to not roll the dice that both answers will be desired results.

I’d like at least 1 mid round OL given the question marks at OT and the lack of depth at OG

 

[Lloyd]

The Steelers can’t stop the run because they play a 2DL set a lot of the time.

And Clown-lin can't figure out why they can't stop the run. Incredible.

 

[steelhurt]

From this years draft with minimal picks, I think DL is first. Must be able to stop the run so that’s my top priority pick.
Next, RB. Need a solid RB that can explode to the hole and get outside. Someone to pair with Warren. I do this in round three.
Round four and later are my depth picks. OL, CB, WR.
As for QB, that ship sailed. Let too many QBs get away waiting on Rodgers who most likely sounds like he’s going to retire.
Sign someone out there like Wentz to compete with and most likely backup Mason.
It’s a lost season, not going anywhere so prepare for 2026 to get your franchise QB.
It’s really ok to have a losing season and maybe go 6-11 but you set yourself up for drafting your QB in 2026.

 

[Lloyd]

From this years draft with minimal picks, I think DL is first. Must be able to stop the run so that’s my top priority pick.
Next, RB. Need a solid RB that can explode to the hole and get outside. Someone to pair with Warren. I do this in round three.
Round four and later are my depth picks. OL, CB, WR.
As for QB, that ship sailed. Let too many QBs get away waiting on Rodgers who most likely sounds like he’s going to retire.
Sign someone out there like Wentz to compete with and most likely backup Mason.
It’s a lost season, not going anywhere so prepare for 2026 to get your franchise QB.
It’s really ok to have a losing season and maybe go 6-11 but you set yourself up for drafting your QB in 2026.

But, but, but....how often do we have to hear: The Steelers don't rebuild, they only reload to compete for the Super Bowl title every year. Now, we know that's total crap. You're trying to tell us going back to the years with Malone there was a realistic chance at contending? Bubby did have a nice run in '89 at season's end. That upset over the Oilers was nice. But those other years of Stoudt, Malone, Brister, Frakengraham, Pickett, Wilson, we knew what time it really was: non-contention. If there was ever a time for a much needed losing season, it's this one. Clown-lin be damned. Tell Rogers to bite it and save $41 mill. That "we only re-load" crap is pure nonsense. I know I'm not telling you anything you don't already know.

 

[Black & Gold Bleeder]

Yet here you are flapping your gums so you can feel like you know something.

 

[Fiji Mariner]

From this years draft with minimal picks, I think DL is first. Must be able to stop the run so that’s my top priority pick.
Next, RB. Need a solid RB that can explode to the hole and get outside. Someone to pair with Warren. I do this in round three.
Round four and later are my depth picks. OL, CB, WR.
As for QB, that ship sailed. Let too many QBs get away waiting on Rodgers who most likely sounds like he’s going to retire.
Sign someone out there like Wentz to compete with and most likely backup Mason.
It’s a lost season, not going anywhere so prepare for 2026 to get your franchise QB.
It’s really ok to have a losing season and maybe go 6-11 but you set yourself up for drafting your QB in 2026.

The Tomlin Steelers Only use 2DL anyways
Just cuz we want a
More intelligent D doesn’t mean it’s coming.

If the right QB or RB is there early they could both come off the board before a DL taken.

Many of those top 30 visits are mid round 3-5 RBs and mid to later round DL…covering their bases in case they have to fill a hole or two early imo

 

[SteelerFan448]

Here's a combination of who I would like the Steelers to consider as well as who I think they will consider:

QB - Jaxson Dart, Shedeur Sanders
RB - Omarion Hampton
WR - Emeka Egbuka, Matthew Golden
TE - none
OL - none
IDL - Derrick Harmon, Walter Nolen, Kenneth Grant, Tyleik Williams, Omarr Norman-Lott
EDGE - none
LB - none
CB - Jahdae Barron, Will Johnson, Trey Amos
S - Nick Emmanwori

A very loose rankings of who I want the Steelers to draft.
1. Emeka Egbuka
2. Jahdae Barron
3. Derrick Harmon
4. Walter Nolen
5. Matthew Golden
6. Will Johnson
7. Omarion Hampton
8. Omarr Norman-Lott
9. Kenneth Grant
10. Jaxson Dart

Overall draft prospects I would target:

QB: Dillon Gabriel, Quinn Ewers, Kyle McCord, Kurtis Rourke
Analysis: None of these QBs intrigue me based on their value. I am up and down on Dart and he'd be a lot more interesting on day 2. I get the tools with Milroe, I just can't get past his inconsistency and how bad he looked against an NFL style defense when facing Michigan in the bowl game. The four I listed I would consider Round 5 or later as developmental backups--I don't see any of them as long-term starters.

RB: Ashton Jeanty, Omarion Hampton, TreVeyon Henderson, Quinshon Judkins, Cam Skattebo, Kaleb Johnson, Bhayshul Tuten, RJ Harvey, DJ Giddens, Damien Martinez
Analysis: If the Steelers want a 1A/1B setup again or a future workhorse, obviously Jeanty (if he falls) or Hampton in the first is the answer. Henderson, Skattebo, and Johnson also fit the mold. The rest I like in a RBC type setup.

WR: Emeka Egbuka, Matthew Golden, Jayden Higgins, Tre Harris, Savion Williams, Jaylin Noel, Tez Johnson, Konata Mumpfield, Kyle Williams
Analysis: I don't know Pickens status beyond this season and the Steelers offense stinks. They've invested in the OL, now let's get some additional playmakers to make this offense fun. Egubka is one of my favorite players for this team as he's a blue collar WR who has the upside to be a high volume WR. The rest have a lot of college production along with athletic upside.

TE: Tyler Warren, Harold Fannin, Luke Lachey
Analysis: Tight end isn't a need, but I won't ignore the position for the right value. Warren is simply a really good player. Fannin has unique athleticism for the position, and I will always consider an Iowa TE in the late rounds.

OL: Clay Webb, Garrett Dellinger, Dylan Fairchild, Tate Ratledge, Tyler Cooper, Jared Wilson, Jack Nelson, Logan Brown, Wyatt Milum, Jalen Travis, Caleb Rogers
Analysis: While the starting 5 appear to be set, there are some unproven spots on the line and there is a big need for depth. I tried to look for experience, athleticism, or a combination of both.

IDL: Derrick Harmon, Walter Nolen, Kenneth Grant, Tyleik Williams, Omarr Norman-Lott, Darius Alexander, T.J. Sanders, Joshua Farmer, Deone Walker, Elijah Roberts, Alfred Collins, Jordan Phillips, JJ Pegues,
Analysis: It would be nice to come away from this draft with the ever popular "replacement for Cam" and a big run stuffer for the middle that Tomlin will never use.

EDGE: James Pearce, David Walker, Quandarrius Robinson, Tyler Baron
Analysis: This won't be a high-priority position, but drafting for depth is always a must, IMO.

LB: Carson Bruener, Brandon George
Analysis: The Steelers have pretty good depth here and I don't think they'll spend any picks on the position. With that said, there is a legacy player out there.

CB: Jahdae Barron, Will Johnson, Trey Amos, Azareye'h Thomas, Maxwell Hairston, Shavon Revel, Cobee Bryant, Zah Frazier, Justin Walley
Analysis: Besides JPJ, who I'm not sure they take if it's not Joey Porter's son, it's crazy to think how many very good CB prospects they've passed on over the years. It's not a position Tomlin seems to value, yet it's a big need, IMO.

S: Nick Emmanwori, Kevin Winston, Xavier Watts, T.J. Mickens, Donovan McMillon
Analysis: Not an immediate need, but what is Fitzpatrick's future with the team beyond 2025?