• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

The Most Bizarre Loss in Steelers History

Steeler Nation

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Joined
Apr 7, 2014
Messages
2,542
Reaction score
4,985
Points
93
The Pittsburgh Steelers first game against the expansion Houston Texans in 2002 was certainly memorable. On both sides of the ball, the Steelers dominated their way to a 24-6 finish, outgaining the Texans 422 yards to 47 yards, controlling 67% of the time of possession (39:41 to 20:19), and leading first downs by a measure of 24-3.

The Steelers defense registered more sacks (4) than completed passes (3) against rookie quarterback David Carr as the Texans were limited to only 10 net passing yards.

The Texans were equally inept on the ground, with starter Jonathan Wells stuffed for a mere 12 yards on 10 carries, replaced the equally ineffective James Allen who tallied only 19 yards on 13 carries. On the day, the Steelers defense controlled the line of scrimmage and stuffed the Texans for 17 plays of no gain or negative yardage.

The Steelers rode the arm quarterback Tommy Maddox, who completed 30 of 57 passes on the day for 325 yards, and their trio of talented wide receivers: Hines Ward (9 catches for 76 yards), Plaxico Burress (6 catches for 83 yards), and Antwaan Randle El (8 catches for 88 yards). Amos Zereoue and Jerome Bettis complimented each other by combining for 99 yards rushing as the Steelers were able to pound out 128 rushing yards as a team for the day.

But if you did not notice, there was one thing missing: who scored the 3 touchdowns to generate the 24 points?

It wasn’t anybody on the Steelers roster, because despite dominating the game in almost every aspect, they lost the game. It was a nightmare day for Maddox, who accounted for 3 of the Steelers 5 turnovers, and despite generating a lot of yardage, saw the worst possible outcomes from his turnovers.

Maddox fumbled on the Steelers opening drive after a 5-yard scramble and it was returned 40 yards by Texans journeyman cornerback Kenny Wright for the only touchdown of his 9-year career.

But it gets worse.

Maddox was twice intercepted Pro Bowl cornerback Aaron Glenn, who returned both for touchdowns of 70-yards and 65-yards respectively.

But it gets worse.

The Steelers were 6-1-1 in their previous 8 games at that point in the season (second only to the Atlanta Falcons 7-0-1) leading up to playing the expansion Texans. It marked the Steelers 3rd loss to an expansion team since 1995.

But it gets worse.

The Texans 47 total yards were the lowest ever by a winning team in NFL history.

Bill Cowher did not consider pulling Maddox, despite having a healthy Kordell Stewart in reserve, and summed up his quarterback’s afternoon very succinctly by saying: “It wasn’t very good.

It also was arguably an important pivot point in the career of Tommy Maddox. At the time, there was some debate on whether Maddox was ready to return after being temporarily paralyzed when leaving the field in an ambulance due to a concussion and spinal cord contusion. Although he did have his moments, Maddox never seemed to be quite the same “Tommy Gun” after the emotional and physical impacts of the injury.

The Steelers still went on to win the AFC North and came within a dropped pass of advancing to the AFC Championship, and the bizarre loss did not cost the Steelers a bye week. But it is a classic example of not reading too much into the stats, because they certainly do not tell the whole story.



Is there another unique Steelers game like this to remember? Click to comment below!

#SteelerNation

Support SteelerNation by clicking here to read the story..
 
Not sure if it's bizarre but the 2017 playoff loss to Jacksonville makes me crazy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMM
The game we dominated the Clowns........except Eric Metcalf returning kicks.
That game haunts my dreams.
 
I didn't quite but wanted to shitsing my pants on that one................ !!!!

I talked about that game for a couple years and even then could hardly believe it.



Salute the nation
 
As soon as I saw the thread title it brought me right back to that game.
I remember saying, “well I’ll never see that again”
Crazy game
 
My first game at Heinz, most bizarre game you've ever seen. We did have a TD called back in the 2nd half. I think it was Hines Ward being called for holding.
 
I listened on the radio and my kids kept coming downstairs to ask if I was OK.



Salute the nation
 
I remember this loss well… and there was one nearly as bad vs the raiders once too…

But this one we just drove all over them then turned it over before scoring lol

Was that the game hwere (fat ***) Jamarcus Russell ran an 80 + yard touchdown on us ?



Salute the nation
 
I thought about the Houston’s game as soon as I read the subject title. Some others:

AFC Championship vs Chargers
Playoff game vs Tebow led Broncos
The recent ties (Detroit, and I think Atlanta?)
Any of the games vs the Raiders
 
It was 90+ and it's the longest run by a QB in NFL history...
As horrifying a memory that play was, there is a DEFINITE sigh of relief knowing it was Terrel Pryor who had that scamper. If Jamarcus Russel ran a 90 yard td on anyone, that franchise needs/needed to fold immediately.
 
As horrifying a memory that play was, there is a DEFINITE sigh of relief knowing it was Terrel Pryor who had that scamper. If Jamarcus Russel ran a 90 yard td on anyone, that franchise needs/needed to fold immediately.
Even in his biggest Purple Drank, Sizzurp stupor, Jamarcus Russel never dreamed of running 90 yards.
 
I remember this loss well… and there was one nearly as bad vs the raiders once too…

But this one we just drove all over them then turned it over before scoring lol
Yes, the 2006 game which was pretty similar. Ben threw 4 picks, 2 for tds, one was returned 100 yds. Raiders won 20-13, completed 5 passes for 50 yds. Steelers out gained Raids' 360-98. This game would go on to illustrate Ben's troubles playing the out West (esp against Raiders), as they would go on to a 2-6 record VS, and 0-4 away. Ben would finish just 2-9 on the left coast.
 
Remember that HOU game unfortunately. Remember just sitting there thinking “what the hell just happened”?! Totally defies any common sense or logic of how sports are supposed to work, yet also goes to show the “any given Sunday” cliche. For me personally, the AFCCG against SD was most heartbreaking. Still see that big TE “drinking” outta the football. I must’ve smoked a pack of Marlboro menthol in about 2 hours after that game 🤣. Thought end of world was here.
 
Well the Turkey Day loss in Detroit with the coin flip has a place. The '94 AFC Championship and the '01 loss at home to the Pats are games I will never understand how they lost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMM
In my humble opinion, the Steelers franchise has never suffered a worse loss. That game was the worst.
My brother went to that game and while leaving totally dejected, realized that he had lost his car keys. Talk about a ****** day!
 
I thought about the Houston’s game as soon as I read the subject title. Some others:

AFC Championship vs Chargers
Playoff game vs Tebow led Broncos
The recent ties (Detroit, and I think Atlanta?)
Any of the games vs the Raiders
Atlanta was back in cowhers day… plex caught what should have been a game winning td as time expired in ot but landed sideways and somehow a foot short of the endzone… his on field awareness was always ******

The recent tie you are referring to is Cleveland, where we blew a decent lead then proceeded to miss the playoffs by that tie iirc

Niether of those were as bad as the Houston loss or the raiders loss…

Speaking of plex and stupid losses he helped take, in one of those bad Raiders losses back in the day in a game where the Steelers trailed late by a score, and were driving late down the field with time ticking off the clock, Plex caught a sideline pass with the clock running and no where near the first down marker and instead of stepping out of bounds, tried to turn upfield and as he was being tackled tried to reach out for more yardage and had a player slap the ball out of his hand and recover it for a game ending fumble

Next to the two times he spiked a live ball that was probably his dumbest moment… but he had plenty even before he accidentally shot himself
 
Atlanta was back in cowhers day… plex caught what should have been a game winning td as time expired in ot but landed sideways and somehow a foot short of the endzone… his on field awareness was always ******

The recent tie you are referring to is Cleveland, where we blew a decent lead then proceeded to miss the playoffs by that tie iirc

Niether of those were as bad as the Houston loss or the raiders loss…

Speaking of plex and stupid losses he helped take, in one of those bad Raiders losses back in the day in a game where the Steelers trailed late by a score, and were driving late down the field with time ticking off the clock, Plex caught a sideline pass with the clock running and no where near the first down marker and instead of stepping out of bounds, tried to turn upfield and as he was being tackled tried to reach out for more yardage and had a player slap the ball out of his hand and recover it for a game ending fumble

Next to the two times he spiked a live ball that was probably his dumbest moment… but he had plenty even before he accidentally shot himself
I’ll always remember Plaxico for catching a pass and then spiking the ball even though he wasn’t down resulting in a fumble. That play ranks up there with Barry Foster not knowing that a kickoff, unlike a punt, landing in the field of play is a live ball that can be recovered by the kicking team.
 
It was a win but the 3-0 victory over the Dolphins on MNF in 2007. The Mud Bowl game when the field fell apart.

 
Top