• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Training Camp Offense Roster Predictions:

madinsomniac

Regular Member
Member
Joined
May 9, 2014
Messages
21,588
Reaction score
24,835
Points
113
Location
LP in the burgh
Steelers 2025 Roster Predictions- Offense

Offense over the past few years has clearly been second fiddle to the D, Not only has there been significantly less money invested in it, it also has had fewer roster spots than the D.

Over the past 5 seasons, the offense has had 24.4 players kept on the initial roster.

The past two seasons, The team has only kept 24 offensive players coming out of camp.

Part 1: Quarterbacks

This is an easy position to Handicap.

The past 5 seasons the team has averaged 3 QBs coming out of camp. The past two seasons it was 3… logic says this year will be 3 too

  • Aaron Rodgers- Clear cut Starter – Roster Secure :QB1
  • Mason Rudolph- Clear cut Backup- Roster Secure: QB2
  • Will Howard- Almost certainly 3rd QB – Roster likely secure QB3

  • -Others with work to do:

  • Skylar Thompson- Potential PS or QB3 – Likely cut. May be kept on PS Only makes 53 man roster if injury concerns are present during camp.


Part 2: Running backs

This Position can go several ways

Total Rbs past 5 years- 4 Total Rbs past 2 years- 3

but a deeper breakdown goes:

Total HBs past 5 years- 3.4 Total Rbs past 2 years- 3

Total FBs past 5 years- 0.6 Total Rbs past 2 years- 0



So its likely with DJ Thomas-Jones injury, we don’t keep a listed FB

Im guessing With Patterson getting cut, there wont be a pure ST guy either

The play here is 3 RBs on the Roster

  • Jaylen Warren – Likely Starter, Roster Spot Secure – RB1
  • Kaleb Johnson- Possible starter, likely backup, Roster spot Secure-RB2
  • Kenneth Gainwell _Possible backup, Roster spot Likely-RB3

  • -Others with work to do:
  • Max Hurleman-
  • Evan Hull
  • Trey Sermon


Part 3: Wide Recievers

This Position has the most variables on O

Total Wrs past 5 years- 5.6 Total Rbs past 2 years- 5.5

In the past 5 years the fewest WRs kept was 5 and the most was 7



So lets say with the extra TEs, we are looking at a likely number of 5 WRs

  • DK Metcalf- Absolute Starter- Spot Secure - WR1
  • Calvin Austin 3 – Possible Starter or Slot, Spot Secure Likely WR2
  • Roman Wilson- Possible Slot Reciver, Spot likely secure-Maybe WR3
  • Robert Woods- Possible top Backup WR- Spot more likely than not- WR4
  • Ben Skowronek- ST ace Wr. Spot possible -WR5

  • -Others with work to do:
  • Scotty Miller-
  • Montana Lemonious Craig
  • Roc Taylor
  • Ke’Shawn Williams
  • Lance McCutcheon






Part 4: Tight Ends

This Position is likely Growing in importance this season

Total TEs past 5 years- 3.2 Total Rbs past 2 years- 3.5

In the past 5 years the fewest WRs kept was 3 and the most was 4



The guess here is 4 TEs are kept

  • Pat Friermuth- Starter 1a- Spot Secure - TE1a
  • Jonnu Smith – Starter 1b- Spot Secure TE1B
  • Darnell Washington- Top Blocking TE- Spot Secure- TE3
  • Connor Heyward- ST ace and H-Back /TE Utility guy, Spot Possible, TE4

  • -Others with work to do:
  • JJ GalBreath
  • (Unnamed Replacement for DJ Thomas-Jones)




Part 5: OL

This Position is Three merged positions in one

Total OL past 5 years- 8.6 Total OL past 2 years- 9

In the past 5 years the fewest OLs kept was 8and the most was 9

With the early injuries, 9 is a safe bet.



By Position:

C: Past 5y – 2 Last 2y -2 --- Most: 2 Fewest:2

G: Past 5y – 3.2 Last 2y -3.5 --- Most: 4 Fewest:2

T: Past 5y – 3.4 Last 2y -3,5 --- Most: 4 Fewest:3





  • Zach Frazier- Starter C- Spot Secure – C1
  • Issac Seumalo – Starter LG- Spot Secure -LG1
  • Mason McCormick- Starter RG- Spot Secure- RG1
  • Broderick Jones- Starter LT, Spot Secure,LT1
  • Troy Fautanu- Starter RT, Spot Secure RT1
  • Calvin Anderson Swing Tackle, Spot Likely, OT3
  • Dylan Cook, Backup Tackle, OT4
  • Spenser Andersen, G/C/T Spot likely OG3/Utility OL
  • C-Ryan MCCollum, C/G Spot Likely, C2/IOL

  • -Others with work to do:
  • Alden Williams OG
  • Stephen Jones OG
  • Doug Nester OG
  • Nick Broeker OG
  • Gareth Warren OT


Predicted Totals for Offense: 24

QB-3

RB-3

WR-5

TE-4

OL-9
 
“Dylan Cook, Backup Tackle, OT4”

Good list, I would move Cook down with the work to do designation. They looked at him closer the other day and I have a feeling they are assessing if he is roster deserving.

Still thinking a vet T might be brought in. I am hoping so…
 
Steelers 2025 Roster Predictions- Offense

Offense over the past few years has clearly been second fiddle to the D, Not only has there been significantly less money invested in it, it also has had fewer roster spots than the D.

Over the past 5 seasons, the offense has had 24.4 players kept on the initial roster.

The past two seasons, The team has only kept 24 offensive players coming out of camp.

Part 1: Quarterbacks

This is an easy position to Handicap.

The past 5 seasons the team has averaged 3 QBs coming out of camp. The past two seasons it was 3… logic says this year will be 3 too

  • Aaron Rodgers- Clear cut Starter – Roster Secure :QB1
  • Mason Rudolph- Clear cut Backup- Roster Secure: QB2
  • Will Howard- Almost certainly 3rd QB – Roster likely secure QB3

  • -Others with work to do:

  • Skylar Thompson- Potential PS or QB3 – Likely cut. May be kept on PS Only makes 53 man roster if injury concerns are present during camp.


Part 2: Running backs

This Position can go several ways

Total Rbs past 5 years- 4 Total Rbs past 2 years- 3

but a deeper breakdown goes:

Total HBs past 5 years- 3.4 Total Rbs past 2 years- 3

Total FBs past 5 years- 0.6 Total Rbs past 2 years- 0



So its likely with DJ Thomas-Jones injury, we don’t keep a listed FB

Im guessing With Patterson getting cut, there wont be a pure ST guy either

The play here is 3 RBs on the Roster

  • Jaylen Warren – Likely Starter, Roster Spot Secure – RB1
  • Kaleb Johnson- Possible starter, likely backup, Roster spot Secure-RB2
  • Kenneth Gainwell _Possible backup, Roster spot Likely-RB3

  • -Others with work to do:
  • Max Hurleman-
  • Evan Hull
  • Trey Sermon


Part 3: Wide Recievers

This Position has the most variables on O

Total Wrs past 5 years- 5.6 Total Rbs past 2 years- 5.5

In the past 5 years the fewest WRs kept was 5 and the most was 7



So lets say with the extra TEs, we are looking at a likely number of 5 WRs

  • DK Metcalf- Absolute Starter- Spot Secure - WR1
  • Calvin Austin 3 – Possible Starter or Slot, Spot Secure Likely WR2
  • Roman Wilson- Possible Slot Reciver, Spot likely secure-Maybe WR3
  • Robert Woods- Possible top Backup WR- Spot more likely than not- WR4
  • Ben Skowronek- ST ace Wr. Spot possible -WR5

  • -Others with work to do:
  • Scotty Miller-
  • Montana Lemonious Craig
  • Roc Taylor
  • Ke’Shawn Williams
  • Lance McCutcheon






Part 4: Tight Ends

This Position is likely Growing in importance this season

Total TEs past 5 years- 3.2 Total Rbs past 2 years- 3.5

In the past 5 years the fewest WRs kept was 3 and the most was 4



The guess here is 4 TEs are kept

  • Pat Friermuth- Starter 1a- Spot Secure - TE1a
  • Jonnu Smith – Starter 1b- Spot Secure TE1B
  • Darnell Washington- Top Blocking TE- Spot Secure- TE3
  • Connor Heyward- ST ace and H-Back /TE Utility guy, Spot Possible, TE4

  • -Others with work to do:
  • JJ GalBreath
  • (Unnamed Replacement for DJ Thomas-Jones)




Part 5: OL

This Position is Three merged positions in one

Total OL past 5 years- 8.6 Total OL past 2 years- 9

In the past 5 years the fewest OLs kept was 8and the most was 9

With the early injuries, 9 is a safe bet.



By Position:

C: Past 5y – 2 Last 2y -2 --- Most: 2 Fewest:2

G: Past 5y – 3.2 Last 2y -3.5 --- Most: 4 Fewest:2

T: Past 5y – 3.4 Last 2y -3,5 --- Most: 4 Fewest:3





  • Zach Frazier- Starter C- Spot Secure – C1
  • Issac Seumalo – Starter LG- Spot Secure -LG1
  • Mason McCormick- Starter RG- Spot Secure- RG1
  • Broderick Jones- Starter LT, Spot Secure,LT1
  • Troy Fautanu- Starter RT, Spot Secure RT1
  • Calvin Anderson Swing Tackle, Spot Likely, OT3
  • Dylan Cook, Backup Tackle, OT4
  • Spenser Andersen, G/C/T Spot likely OG3/Utility OL
  • C-Ryan MCCollum, C/G Spot Likely, C2/IOL

  • -Others with work to do:
  • Alden Williams OG
  • Stephen Jones OG
  • Doug Nester OG
  • Nick Broeker OG
  • Gareth Warren OT


Predicted Totals for Offense: 24

QB-3

RB-3

WR-5

TE-4

OL-9
Berm endorses this list...
 
Thanks Mad.

Unless they being in another OL candidate like Bakhtiari, the only real decision seems to be TE4 vs WR6. Heyward vs Miller at this point, and it seems far more likely that Lil Heyward makes the grade.
The Steelers would be better squad if there was another WR or TE that could take this spot and be more productive on O/ST.
 
Definitely agree on 23 of 24

I think Cook is on the shakiest ground yielding his spot to a FA pickup. He’s been around a couple years now and yet to make the jump…maybe this is the year, but not holding my breath on it.

I think his spot is nabbed by a vet OL pickup or a possible WR6 if someone really shows out in camp/preseason.

I personally feel Calvin Anderson should be upgraded but that just comes from my personal assessment that the depth on the OL outside of McCullom seems very thin. I wouldn’t want him forced into a starting role with Cook as the “depth” behind him. Our QB is too old to play those sorts of games at tackle imo.

McCullom and Spencer Anderson as IOL depth is pretty decent, especially compared to the void at tackle depth.
 
Pretty much my own assessment as of now. The only question is 3 TE or 4 with Baby Heyward-he can wear many hats on the team. The WR situation is a curious one to me and probably the rest of the fanbase that pays attention. I like Skowronek. He’s a big boy who just plays the way we like Steeler receivers to play. If a WR2 is brought in it becomes a question of who what what position do you sacrifice for that? Honestly, if the league wants more games from teams, they should expand the rosters to 55 players. That would make life simpler
 
Honestly, if the league wants more games from teams, they should expand the rosters to 55 players. That would make life simpler

I have never understood why they only dress 46, but are allowed an emergency QB & 2 PS elevations.
Just allow all 53 to dress….
 
“Dylan Cook, Backup Tackle, OT4”

Good list, I would move Cook down with the work to do designation. They looked at him closer the other day and I have a feeling they are assessing if he is roster deserving.

Still thinking a vet T might be brought in. I am hoping so…

He took over for Broderick Jones on the top unitwhen he left for injury reasons. Now this is probably cause they were getting reps for Calvin Anderson at RT, at least that is the company line, But Cook may have also been getting a look in case Jones isnt the answer...
much like AV, Cook is a major project with huge upside. He was a qb/LS before switching to Tackle late in his college career...
much like AV, was when he finally got a chance he is 27 , so its possible they simply are seeing how far he progressed technique wise...

I think he is still the likely 4OT unless a trade option becomes available... and with the lack of good OL guys right now in the nfl... that is unlikely
 
Looks pretty spot on. Think Warren/Johnson will look like Harris/ Warren but leaning to Warren. The kid will have to show a lot in pass pro including pre season to become the lead.
 
I’m reading and hearing that Broderick Jones who does have a soft tissue injury but that he had gotten off to a slow start.
He’s key to the success of this OL and this offense.
Hopefully he can play much better at his natural LT position.
 
I’m reading and hearing that Broderick Jones who does have a soft tissue injury but that he had gotten off to a slow start.
He’s key to the success of this OL and this offense.
Hopefully he can play much better at his natural LT position.

I saw that too, but deep down I think this is just our fan base being hyper critical. I don’t even think he’s had a full practice in pads yet.
 
I’m reading and hearing that Broderick Jones who does have a soft tissue injury but that he had gotten off to a slow start.
He’s key to the success of this OL and this offense.
Hopefully he can play much better at his natural LT position.
If we look at this honestly and open-mindedly - PATIENCE will be required as Broderick has to UNLEARN his RT habits and tendencies. Why? Because Dan Moore Jr. could only play LT.

I remember Broderick at LT in Georgia and he was an absolute beast. Yes, the game is faster and he's facing stronger players; but if this kid can get back to that - this OL is going to be very good indeed...
 
If we look at this honestly and open-mindedly - PATIENCE will be required as Broderick has to UNLEARN his RT habits and tendencies. Why? Because Dan Moore Jr. could only play LT.

I remember Broderick at LT in Georgia and he was an absolute beast. Yes, the game is faster and he's facing stronger players; but if this kid can get back to that - this OL is going to be very good indeed...
They said Jones was a beast due to freak athleticism, but he lacked good technique. I definitely think the Steelers mishandled his progression though. He didn't seem to interested in learning RT or working at it. Im hoping moving him been to his natural spot and protecting for Rodgers will give him some motivation.
 
He took over for Broderick Jones on the top unitwhen he left for injury reasons. Now this is probably cause they were getting reps for Calvin Anderson at RT, at least that is the company line, But Cook may have also been getting a look in case Jones isnt the answer...
much like AV, Cook is a major project with huge upside. He was a qb/LS before switching to Tackle late in his college career...
much like AV, was when he finally got a chance he is 27 , so its possible they simply are seeing how far he progressed technique wise...

I think he is still the likely 4OT unless a trade option becomes available... and with the lack of good OL guys right now in the nfl... that is unlikely
Perhaps. I think they have to see progression from where he was at last season to stick, but you might be right.
 
If he makes the team he'll be dubbed "Roc Nation"...
Or Rokafewlloa Nation

If he screws up people won’t remember his name.

“That guy you know messed up”

Who?

That one undrafted guy

Yeah who?

Beats the hell out of me.


😅
 
Jones also supposedly had an injury (elbow?) from training camp last year that they said wouldn't be 100% all year. That seemed to get swept under the rug so not sure how much stock to put into that. If true combine that with playing out of position and it could be the cause of his struggles last year. The steelers have scheme problems but the concerning thing to me was seeing Jones get beat 1v1 too many times. I heard he slimmed down so hopefully he will be more healthy and motivated
 
I saw that too, but deep down I think this is just our fan base being hyper critical. I don’t even think he’s had a full practice in pads yet.




Today was FIRST PAD day.


Salute the nation
 
Today was FIRST PAD day.


Salute the nation
Funny enough, after I responded, I thought that was the first practice and it got stormed out.

But that kinda emphasizes my point. Jones has been far from perfect through his first couple years.

But he was never drafted to be the RT. We needed a RT, and he got to get some experience. We would’ve been in deeper trouble if jones didn’t fill in at RT.

But my point is really that I think if one position looks rough in shorts it’s probably going to be OL.
Let him get into pads, shake off the rust as he goes back to LT and then let’s see if there’s improvement.

There’s going to be a curve here, we aren’t going to see improvement before we even see him suit up.
 
They said Jones was a beast due to freak athleticism, but he lacked good technique. I definitely think the Steelers mishandled his progression though. He didn't seem to interested in learning RT or working at it. Im hoping moving him been to his natural spot and protecting for Rodgers will give him some motivation.

I've read articles from both sides of the isle with Jones. One article says the coaching staff doesn't think he takes his job seriously, another article saying that he watched the film, saw he was sluggish out of his stance, and got in the gym and slimmed down 20 lbs while also adding strength. The coaching staff absolutely mishandled his progression...you trade up to draft a very talented and athletic yet raw LT because you recognize that is the weak link on the OL. You then force him to learn a new position because your weak link on the OL is even worse on the other side.

And the funniest thing about the whole situation, none of this is Dan Moore's fault. He in fact started to practice reps at RT the moment he heard Jones name announced on draft night. But the coaches didn't let that development to play out either. Massive mismanagement all around that could have lasting long term effects.
 
You then force him to learn a new position because your weak link on the OL is even worse on the other side.

And the funniest thing about the whole situation, none of this is Dan Moore's fault. He in fact started to practice reps at RT the moment he heard Jones name announced on draft night. But the coaches didn't let that development to play out either. Massive mismanagement all around that could have lasting long term effects.

See but then there’s the other side of this coin.
I think getting the raw athletic LT onto the field was the right move. First of all to get him that experience, but also because I think you’re underestimating or forgetting just how bad Moore was at RT. Giving him time to develop there would’ve likely gotten somebody seriously injured. It was bad bad. He was serviceable ant LT, while cuttable at best at RT. And I read the opposite, that Moore wasn’t actually super interested in learning RT.

I don’t think fans would’ve been happy either way. They (we) never really loved Moore from the jump.
If we would’ve moved him to RT And filled jones in at LT it would’ve been the same “mismanagement,” conversation.
 
Top