Nick Cage as John Madden

[Steeltime]

Joaquin Phoenix reaction when asked if he is a better actor than Russell Crowe:

 

[CoolieMan]

Joaquin Phoenix is indeed awesome. Gladiator, Signs, and Walk the Line show his skills.

Great actor? Yes.

Better than Russell Crowe? No.

joaquin sucked in Gladiator

 

[Steeltime]

joaquin sucked in Gladiator

Disagree. He was an exquisite villain. Sociopath, coward, liar, manipulator, someone who shows up after the fighting is over to pretend he was part of the battle. Excellent in portraying the evil antagonist.

 

[CoolieMan]

Disagree. He was an exquisite villain. Sociopath, coward, liar, manipulator, someone who shows up after the fighting is over to pretend he was part of the battle. Excellent in portraying the evil antagonist.

meh

 

[Steeltime]

meh

I suspect the problem here, Coolie, is that Phoenix's superb characterization of Commodus in Gladiator paled in comparison to the glowing Klieg-light brilliance of one Russell Crowe.

That simply proves my original point.

 

[WindyCitySteel]

Joaquin Phoenix is indeed awesome. Gladiator, Signs, and Walk the Line show his skills.

Great actor? Yes.

Better than Russell Crowe? No.

Respectfully disagree but this is all subjective and kind of fun.

Another guy not mentioned here is Geoffrey Rush — anyone else a fan?

 

[slashsteel]

Respectfully disagree but this is all subjective and kind of fun.

Another guy not mentioned here is Geoffrey Rush — anyone else a fan?

Good actor but not top tier. Played a good pirate.

 

[WindyCitySteel]

I suspect the problem here, Coolie, is that Phoenix's superb characterization of Commodus in Gladiator paled in comparison to the glowing Klieg-light brilliance of one Russell Crowe.

That simply proves my original point.

I mean, it’s hard to argue with is well-thought out, cogent, detailed analysis.

 

[WindyCitySteel]

Good actor but not top tier. Played a good pirate.

I think of him more in movies like Shine and The King’s Speech, but he was a good pirate.

 

[Steeltime]

I mean, it’s hard to argue with is well-thought out, cogent, detailed analysis.

Damn it, now I wish I had authored my own analysis rather than turning to ChatGPT ...

Uhh, I mean, thank you.