• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Quarterback Scouting Thread

SteelerFan448 said:
A big part is how much you trust Mike McCarthy to put a young QB in position to succeed. Also, what is the ceiling/floor for each?

To me, guys like Simpson, Nussmeier, or Klubnik have the upside of a Brock Purdy. All are undersized and have limited arm strength.

Allar doesn't have the clutch gene, but at least has special traits. His arm allows him to make throws not everyone in the NFL can make. The big question is, can McCarthy coach out the negatives, or at least work around them?
Click to expand...



This is my version as well. Thanks for all your great post(s) 448, appreciate you.

Currently, i think the risk is worth the reward.

I also think he will go in the day 2 draft.




Salute the nation
 
Drink IRON City said:
This is my version as well. Thanks for all your great post(s) 448, appreciate you.

Currently, i think the risk is worth the reward.

I also think he will go in the day 2 draft.
Click to expand...
Allar and/or Beck will go way earlier than some think. Depending on what teams want, I could see either going early in the second round.
 
SteelerFan448 said:
Allar and/or Beck will go way earlier than some think. Depending on what teams want, I could see either going early in the second round.
Click to expand...
I wouldn’t pick any of them earlier than 3.

( way off my earlier stance)

I think with this unattractive class they will be overdrafting. I have no desire for the Steelers to follow suit with their plethora of needs.
 
slashsteel said:
I wouldn’t pick any of them earlier than 3.

( way off my earlier stance)

I think with this unattractive class they will be overdrafting. I have no desire for the Steelers to follow suit with their plethora of needs.
Click to expand...
I'd be okay with it, fully trusting Mike McCarthy's QB evaluation. The Steelers have needs everywhere with QB being far and away the top need. We're paying him a lot of money to coach up the next young QB for this franchise.

Waiting a year could be interesting.

Julian Sayin and Arch Manning will battle for the top spot--I think it will go to Manning assuming moderate improvement. As long as Dante Moore stays the course, he should go top-5 as well. Seriously, if these guys don't bomb, we will see 3 QBs go in the top 5 picks. The rest becomes a crapshoot.

Maiava, Sellers, Sorsby all have the size and arm talent, but questions. I'd love for Maiava or Sorsby to light it up and be in range for the Steelers. Sellers just has too many questions for me, particularly his lack of TD passes.

Chambliss lacks size yet showed he can be electric in a big-game setting. Still, that size issue is significant, IMO.

Leavitt and Mateer are a combination of Baker-lite or a max upside of Bo Nix, IMO.
 
topseed said:
Nah. You are confusing talent with measurables. Yes, Allar has the prototypical size. Yes, he has a strong arm. Those are physical traits, not talent. If he were talented, his physicality would translate into great ability. It doesn't, because he isn't mentally talented.

And I'm saying Allar won't be better than Mendoza, because he lacks the mental ability. Allar clearly doesn't have that "clutch" gene that so many great quarterbacks possess. He chokes in big moments. He panics when the game is on the line. Mendoza doesn't. @tapeANaspirin2it should know that better than anybody, after watching Mendoza drive Indiana down the field with pinpoint passes in the final seconds of their win over Penn State a few months ago.
Click to expand...

So talent is just on field success in college? Maybe we can get Stetson Bennett.

You want to use the term physical traits. OK. NFL teams draft Physical Traits in rd 1. Drew Allar has the best physical traits of any QB in this draft.

Who's talking about Mendoza? He's going with a top pick. I suppose if you need to hear it, I'd take Mendoza over Allar. But yes, Allar does have more physical talents than Mendoza. Mendoza wasn't a big target in the portal last year.

You've gone out on a limb that Heisman winner and projected #1 overall pick Fernando Mendoza is talented. Maybe you can grace us with your list of the "talented" QBs in this draft.
 
Badcat said:
Partially, yes. The kid makes dumb decisions with the football like throwing a go ball when you need 3 yards for a first down. Situational football is coached and Franklin was piss poor at. It isn't farfetched to believe it rubbed off on baby faced junior Franklin.
Click to expand...
Wait, didn't you say earlier in this thread that Franklin forced Allar to play turtle ball? Which one is it?

Sorry, it wasn't Franklin or turtle ball that caused a simple first down throw to be handed to Oregon in overtime. It was a shltty pass by the quarterback, who was under no pressure, yet never saw the safety undercut the route.
Badcat said:
Look, if you want label the kid a bust right out of the gate then go for it, it's a free country. But if there is a chance that McCarthy can QB guru Allar into even a serviceable back-up that sends Rudy packing his bags, then why not spend a fourth-round pick on him?
Click to expand...
I watched Allar break my heart for years at Penn State, and I don't want him anywhere near the Steelers. Serviceable backup quarterbacks aren't that hard to come by -- I'll gladly take my chances with somebody else.
 
tapeANaspirin2it said:
So talent is just on field success in college? Maybe we can get Stetson Bennett.
Click to expand...
Where the f*ck did I say that?
tapeANaspirin2it said:
You want to use the term physical traits. OK. NFL teams draft Physical Traits in rd 1. Drew Allar has the best physical traits of any QB in this draft.
Click to expand...
And yet Allar won't go in round one, because despite his glorious physical traits, even the Browns know he doesn't have what it takes above his neck.
tapeANaspirin2it said:
Who's talking about Mendoza? He's going with a top pick. I suppose if you need to hear it, I'd take Mendoza over Allar. But yes, Allar does have more physical talents than Mendoza. Mendoza wasn't a big target in the portal last year.
Click to expand...
YOU said that Allar is undisputedly "the most talented quarterback in this draft. Period." That would include him being more talented than Mendoza, would it not? So mental acuity at the QB position means nothing to you?
tapeANaspirin2it said:
You've gone out on a limb that Heisman winner and projected #1 overall pick Fernando Mendoza is talented. Maybe you can grace us with your list of the "talented" QBs in this draft.
Click to expand...
And you've gone out on a limb to say that Drew Allar is more talented than said Heisman winner and projected #1 overall pick. Which, again, only makes it somewhat likely that you're his uncle.

I haven't watched the other quarterbacks nearly to the same extent, but the dude from Arkansas seems like an interesting prospect. Maybe you and DK can pop some video up on Taylen Green, and see what a tall quarterback with outstanding speed actually looks like. Not a guy who runs like he has a load in his pants pretending to be some kind of dual-threat player.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top