I think that is where people tend to close their vision off. Because even a coordinator with a boatload of suck can have good plays. Doesn't mean the suck scale isn't still pointing down.
I see that with our players too, fans refusing to give players on their suck list credit.
Sure they might overall suck but a good play is a good play.
According to Tomlins conference he says it is always a collective effort. So if we are to blame one or give credit to one then other should receive their due too.
It is a collective effort, I've been an OC at several levels and there is A LOT of input from different people.
1. Scheme is week to week depending on your opposition's strength and weakness. Coaches huddle and discuss which personnel packages to use, install new ones if needed, discuss personnel in those packages due to poor play or injuries. This is where the Head coach has a lot of say. If he wants run heavy 80/20 or more balanced attack or in Mike Tomlin's case to not throw to the middle of the field to reduce risks. We even discuss changing the QB's progression chart on certain plays.
2. Install the playbook for the week based on the packages and personnel. For instance, I had an RPO scheme with a talented running QB who went down with an ankle sprain. The backup was a lefty with stone feet. So, we switched to a play action style and incorporated some wildcat plays to keep some of the RPO packages in play.
3. Film and group breakouts are where we pitch the Scheme, packages, and strategies and we receive input from players here as well. sometimes they see things on the field that we either don't think about or miss on film.
4. Assistant coaches are a godsend during a game. It's difficult to call plays, strategize, keep packages at the ready, and diagnose what the defense is doing with your sets. I usually focus on the trenches; assistants will focus on backers and secondary and the opposing sideline to see what personnel packages might be at the ready. We talk in real time as the play happens and boom, it's time for the next call.
Man, do I miss it. Writing that brought back a flood of memories.