I would definitely bring in Taylor. If healthy, he would really help stop the run.
For sure, the only question would be how that knee is holding up. The Browns are on the books for his full $5M salary, would be sweet to sign him to a friendly, prove-it deal. If he beats out McClendon great, if not he adds depth.
Taylor has all the traits of an above the line 3-4 NT and he's only 27. Don't see any negatives bringing in the big boy for a workout.
Some snipets from his scouting profiles:
Phil Taylor Scouting Report
http://walterfootball.com/scoutingreport2011ptaylor_greg.php#W5CJR70Cill6fXJL.99
Strengths:
Massive frame and carries weight well
Great strength and power
Violent, quick hands and uses them well
Can push pocket with bull rush
Run-stuffing anchor
Space eater who occupies blockers
Agile for his size with good balance
Mean streak
Scheme versatile nose tackle
http://www.nfl.com/draft/2011/profiles/phil-taylor?id=2495237
Taylor possesses the rare size and natural brute strength NFL front offices are looking for in a potential 3-4 nose tackle or two-gaper. Can anchor against the run, fight through double teams, uses his hands well, and doesn't necessarily need to come off the field on third down with his adequate pass rushing ability and good feet. A tendency to play high, limited range, in-game durability and some off-the-field red flags do hurt his stock. However, prospects with Taylor's size and ability don't grow on trees, so he shouldn't last past the middle rounds.
http://www.sportingnews.com/nfl/story/2011-03-14/scouting-report-baylor-dt-phil-taylor
Strengths: Is a massive player with the ideal build of a 3-4 nose tackle. Changes directions quickly to beat one-on-one pass blocks. Can drive offensive linemen into the quarterback to force the early pass or get a sack. Has the rare size and strength to hold his ground vs. double-team run blocks. Displays the athleticism to come down the line and make tackles on inside runs.
Weaknesses: Is raw. Has more potential than production. Does not consistently rush the quarterback aggressively. Fails to consistently maintain good leverage throughout the play. Has conditioning issues; tends to wear down in games and does not play with good effort on every snap.
Bottom line: Taylor's value will increase at the next level because of the high number of NFL teams playing 3-4 schemes. He began college at Penn State and was en route to becoming a big part of the team's defense but was dismissed from the team in '08 because of off-field issues. Last offseason, he finally became committed to eating right and working hard in the weight room, which helped him to have a good 2010 season. At the Senior Bowl, he looked bigger and stronger than any of the other linemen but still struggled to consistently be a dominant player because of inconsistent technique and aggressiveness. There is little doubt Taylor has the size, strength and athleticism to be a good nose tackle and likely will be drafted higher than we have him rated. However, spending a first- or second-round pick on a player with off-field issues is always a risk.
Browns Film Room: Phil Taylor
http://www.draftbrowns.com/2013/05/browns-film-room-phil-taylor/
In his first two seasons as a pro, Taylor has regularly showed off the talent that made him a first round draft choice. In 24 games (1,015 snaps), he has produced 49 tackles (24 assisted), five sacks, one pass defensed, one forced fumble, and one fumble recovery. Taylor missed the first eight games of the 2012 season with a torn pectoral and never seemed to make his way back in to optimal physical condition.
In the Run Game
Phil Taylor is extremely stout against the run. He consistently shows good hand placement and he rarely gets moved off of his spot. His surprising athletic ability allows him to quickly shift down the line of scrimmage in pursuit and he shows very good awareness and instincts when adjusting his pursuit angles. Phil Taylor ranked 13th in “Run Stop Percentage” amongst all defensive tackles that recorded a defensive snap on a run play during the 2012 season.
Rushing the Passer
Phil Taylor is a deceptively effective pass rusher. He possesses the strength and technique to push the pocket and combines them with surprising athletic ability, good closing burst, and a high motor. Taylor utilizes a very effective swim move and he is also an effective bull rusher. Phil Taylor ranked 42nd in “Pass Rush Productivity” amongst all defensive tackles that recorded a defensive snap on a pass play during the 2012 season.
Conclusion
At only 25 years old (birthday was April 7th), the sky is the limit for Phil Taylor. He is much more athletic and plays with a much higher motor than most players his size (6’3″ tall and between 320 and 350 lbs.). In moving to the position that many projected him to be best at prior to the 2011 draft, Taylor is expected to be a key cog in Browns’ defensive coordinator Ray Horton’s defensive scheme.
Moving forward, it is very important that Phil Taylor keeps himself in top physical condition. During his first two seasons, Taylor struggled with consistency and I believe that Taylor’s conditioning had a big impact on the inconsistencies. If Taylor hopes to take the next step toward becoming one of the top defensive tackles in the NFL, he is going to have to stay healthy, keep himself in shape, and keep working hard on refining his technique.