Game Balls, Game Goats & FU's...........week 8........vs Giants

[paperclip]

It's a very difficult game/sport. Yes, I think that 3rd quarter stat is pretty impressive.

 

[Ike Kelly]

That is NOT a credible explanation. He HAS to know that ALL scoring plays are reviewed. Let's say for the sake of argument that he COULD challenge under those circumstances.

So he is going to challenge and expect that the guys who just overturned the TD and called the incompletion are going to review the same footage and this time rule that they are reversing themselves??

Just stupid.

See post #14, Replay Assist took place before the usual scoring play review and made the determination of incomplete pass correct, by rule. If a HC knew RA took place, then he would know a challenge flag is not available to use. Drink’s explanation is credible. RA is brand new this year and its use isn’t yet consistent.

Wouldn’t be surprised if the competition committee recommends a change in the two feet rule to incorporate the same foot twice. Otherwise how is it one knee or one elbow or hip qualifies and the same foot twice doesn’t?

 

[Drink IRON City]

That is NOT a credible explanation. He HAS to know that ALL scoring plays are reviewed. Let's say for the sake of argument that he COULD challenge under those circumstances.

So he is going to challenge and expect that the guys who just overturned the TD and called the incompletion are going to review the same footage and this time rule that they are reversing themselves??

Just stupid.

I was just relaying my interpretation of his explanation. To me, it was an excuse given with him knowing better but didn't want to admit it.


Salute the nation