That is just it. Lewis' claim to fame was that he was second in PD in his fourth year when he had finally played himself to the starting lineup to play 16 games. All that means is that QB' s weren't afraid him. All these PDs and he got zero interceptions. At the time he left, he was not significantly different from Allen in any way.
I wonder who is second in th league in PD now? We should make sure that guy is locked up.
Good point, and Keenan was indeed thrown at a LOT that season. And we've discussed that before: PDs and INTs usually (not always, but usually) suggest a guy is being targeted by QBs. But there's more to the equation than JUST that. Lewis played a lot of snaps that year, more than most CBs. And on all of those targets, he gave up just an 80.7 rating in coverage, which was well above average. That was a better number than some good to great corners - Ike (in his last good season), Sean Smith, Leon Hall, etc. He wasn't awesome, and he gave up some big catches late in the year, but he was clearly an ascending player. Not the kind that you break the bank to keep, but that's the thing - he didn't require a break-the-bank contract. The Saints signed him for 5yr/$25.6M with $10M guaranteed. That's a little less than we just signed Cortez for, and he's awful.
True, Keenan was merely above average in 2012 in my opinion. But the fact that he's now an upper-tier CB means that, at best, our coaches and FO failed to recognize an ascending talent. They then compounded that mistake by giving Lewis' exact contract to Cortez Allen, who's now been benched three times in a calendar year. There's some hindsight in that reasoning, sure, but coaches are at least
somewhat responsible for not identifying talent before it becomes great. The Browns' FO deserved at least
some blame for taking Gerard Warren over LaDainian Tomlinson. No, you don't crucify them as sheer idiots for that one mistake alone, but if you're evaluating their talent evaluation performance, you certainly note on their resume that they ****** that one up. And let's not pretend the Lewis/Allen decision is the ONLY player evaluation fuckup Tombert has made.
The reason it bothers me so much is that Tomlin is a DB coach. It's his claim to fame and the reason he became a DC, then a HC. And he's failed to develop and keep one single worthwhile DB in 7.5 years. Lewis is the only one that turned into anything under Tomlin, and he was cut loose at the beginning of his prime with no effort to keep him. It's like hiring Andy Reid or Mike Martz but never developing even a mediocre passing game.