WOW a silver lining has been spotted in that there dark cloud...thanks FSF, I needed that.
You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to FSF again.
You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to FSF again.
Appreciate much to you both. Keep in mind I am not boasting I know something you all don't know or anything else like that. The simple fact of the matter is how good Jarvis Jones is going to be up to Jarvis Jones commitment and work ethic. I can tell you something, not you nor me have any idea what Jarvis Jones is prepared to do and what he is doing to prepare for the opportunity that exists for him in 2015.
I remember having this debate with Vader about Jason Worilds prior to the 2013 season. Vader of course, was down on Worilds -- insisting that if he really were any good he would have shown it by then. And he never provided anything substantial to back up his debate -- especially when you consider he was drafted while the Steelers had James Harrison and Lamar Woodley already in place -- how could you really expect Worilds to break into that starting line-up:
- 2008-2011: The Harrison/Woodley combination combined for 90 combined sacks -- 22.5 sacks per year.
- 2012: The Harrison/Woodley combination had 10 sacks between them -- with Worilds starting 3 of 16 games and having 5 sacks in fill in duty at ROLB and LOLB.
- 2013-2014: Jason Worilds -- started all 16 games in back to back years and had 8 & 7.5 sacks.
Now who won that debate? I does suppose it does come out to what your expectation was because Jason Worilds definitely was productive, but he wasn't at the level of Joey Porter, James Harrison or even Lamar Woodley before him. And looking back, knowing what we know now -- Jason Worilds walked away from what would have been the biggest contract of his life in Free Agency this year because he had other priorities.
So here is the question, what is your expectation of Jarvis Jones? If he were to match the success level of Jason Worilds in his first full year of starting and ended up with 8 sacks, would you be disappointed?
Here's a fair approximation of what Jarvis Jones could be worth. The Steelers have featured really 6 primary OLB combos since 2000; featuring Jason Gildon, Joey Porter, Clark Haggans, James Harrison, Lamar Woodley and Jason Worilds. Here's an analysis of each -- starting with Porter taking over for Carlos Emmons. Note that not one OLB started any sooner than year two and look at the relative production increase from the year they were a part time or reserve player to what they did when they assumed the starting OLB roles:
Carlos Emmons final season with Jason Gildon; Joey Porter rookie
- 1999: Carlos Emmons 16/16 6.0 sacks, 1 INT, 3 FF
- 1999: Jason Gildon 16/16 8.5 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FF
- 1999: Joey Porter 16/0 2 sacks, 1 FF, 2 FR, 1 TD
Carlos Emmons best season -- 1999; 6.0 sacks, 1 INT, 3 FF (2nd season as starter, 4th in NFL)
Career Highlights: Emmons never quite matched his pass rush production that he attained in 1999 with the Steelers, he was signed by the Eagles as an UFA and was a solid starter on their defense during their 4 consecutive years reaching the NFC Championship and finally winning it in 2004, but of course failed to beat the Pats in the Super Bowl.
Jason Gildon best season -- 2001: First Team All Pro/Pro Bowl; 12 sacks, 1 INT, 3 FF, 2 FR (6th year as a starter, 8th in the NFL)
Career Highlights: setting Steelers All Time Sack Record (77), 1 time First Team All Pro/3 Pro Bowls -- key part of 2 Steelers teams that lost outright fluke games in AFC Championship due to Kordell Stewart 3 INT and special teams meltdowns to a pair of teams (Patriots and Broncos) that were circumventing the rules and caught
Joey Porter first season starting with Jason Gildon
- 2000: Joey Porter 16/16 10.5 sacks, 1 INT, 1 FR, 1 FF, 1 TD, 1 SFTY
- 2000: Jason Gildon 16/16 13.5 sacks, 0 INT, 4 FF
Joey Porter's best season -- 2002: First Team All Pro/Pro Bowl; 9 sacks, 4 INT, 2 FF, 2 FR (3rd year as a starter, 4th in the NFL)
Career Highlight: The entire 2005 post season Joey Porter was the heart and soul of that championship run as he compiled 3 sacks but most importantly how his challenge and calling the heavily favored Colts "soft" really rallied the team to the "upset" (Steelers were equal to better than Colts despite the Colts record) and how he got into the Seahawks heads -- in particularly the TE Stevens -- without Porter that Super Bowl run doesn't happen, 1 time First Team All Pro/3 Pro Bowls -- Joey Porter left an all time image with the Steelers -- his best statistical season came with the Dolphins with 17.5 sacks in 2008 (even more than DPOY Harrison with Steelers in same season) but his years with the Steelers were special -- easily could have been 3 time Super Bowl Champion with Steelers.
Jason Gildon final Season with Joey Porther, Clark Haggans 3rd season
- 2003: Jason Gildon 16/16 6 sacks, 1 INT, 1 FR, 1 FF
- 2003: Joey Porter 14/14 5 sacks, 0 INT, 1 FR, 1 FF
- 2003: Clark Haggans 16/2 1 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FR
Clark Haggans first season starting with Joey Porter
- 2004: Clark Haggans 13/13 6 sacks, 0 INT, 1 FR
- 2004: Joey Porter 15/15 7 sacks, 0 INT, 1 FR
Clark Haggan's best season -- 2005: 9 sacks, 4 INT, 2 FF, 2 FR (2nd year as a starter, 6th in the NFL)
Career Highlights; Haggans was the "silent" quality OLB of the 2000's -- do we ever mention him, but he was the starting OLB on the rare 15-1 2004 team that was #1 in total defense, won the most games consecutive games in Steelers history and lost to the Patriots who had all their signals in the 2004 AFC Championship but won the 2005 Super Bowl contributing one of the 3 sacks and drawing the holding penalty that Seahawks fans felt their OT should have gotten away with (even claimed he was offsides but Haggans perfectly timed the count) -- without that hold it would have been a sack. Haggans left as quietly as he came in, taking over for a great in Gildon and yielding to a great in Woodley -- but was quality during his short tenure.
Joey Porter final season with Clark Haggans, James Harrison 5th season
- 2006: Joey Porter 16/15 7.0 sacks, 2 INT, 0 FF 1 TD
- 2006: Clark Haggans 15/15 6.0 sacks, 1 INT, 1 FR, 2 FF
- 2006: James Harrison 11/1 0 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FF
James Harrison first year starting with Clark Haggans in final season, Lamar Woodley rookie
- 2007: James Harrison 16/15 8.5 sacks, 1 INT, 3 FF
- 2007: Clark Haggans 16/16 4.0 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FR
- 2007: Lamar Woodley 13/0 4.0 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FR
James Harrison's best season -- 2008: Defensive MVP/First Team All Pro/Pro Bowl 16.0 sacks, 1 INT, 0 FF, 7 FF, 1 SFTY. (2nd season as starter, 7th in NFL)
Career Highlights: 100 yard INT reception return in Super Bowl XLIII, 2 Time First Team All Pro/5 Pro Bowls, 2007 MNF game vs. Ravens 9 tackles 4.5 sacks, 1 INT,1 FF, 1 FR. Harrison's final chapter with the Steelers has yet to be written, he was the best LB on the team last year -- but one should really take that as a testament to how great Harrison is -- even past his prime. He'll not make the Hall of Fame; as an UFA who was a practice squad player and really didn't make the team as reserve till 2004; he lost too many years of production to be considered -- but one has to wonder with the glimpses seen in his one start in 2004 vs. Cleveland (after Porter was ejected in pre-game fight vs. Browns) where he recorded his first sack in first start and with his production of 3 sacks in 2005 as well as the way he easily leaped over Antonio Gates trying to tackle him on an interception -- maybe Haggans should have been the one in reserve all along? Harrison was so dominant from the time he started in 2007 -- Lawrence Timmons was drafted to take over the spot but had no chance the way Harrison owned it with Porter's departure, Harrison was the 2nd best player on the 2000's defense (Troy Polamalu) and was unblockable -- although he was brought back last year only after desperation once he was in football shape he was at times just as dominant -- this year he has a legit chance to own the Steelers sack record -- trailing Gildon 77 to 71.5.
Lamar Woodley's first year starting with James Harrison
- 2008: Lamar Woodley 15/15 11.5 sacks, 1 INT, 4 FF, 2 FF, 1 TD
- 2008: James Harrison 15/15 16.0 sacks, 1 INT, 0 FF, 7 FF, 1 SFTY
Lamar Woodley's best season -- 2009: Pro Bowl 13.5 sacks, 0 INT, 1 FR, 1 FF, 1 TD (2nd season as a starter, 3rd in NFL)
Career Highlights/Legacy: setting NFL record with minimum 2 sacks in each of first 4 playoff games, including on the final offensive attempt forcing fumble on Kurt Warner in Super Bowl XLIII; recovering fumbles that led to scores to beat Ravens in prime time games in 2008/2010 (decided division championships). Woodley was shaping up to be the next great Steeler LB, one who would begin and end his career with dominance, but in 2011 his weight began to be a problem and he wasn't training hard enough, as a result he was often injured. The 2011 team had a legit chance if it stayed healthy to reach the Super Bowl, but Woodley's injuries were a part of the early exit. Then he really didn't make an effort to come back in shape -- taking a fat contract the team is still paying. The reality is if Woodley had been working as hard as Timmons has -- we''d not be worrying about the weakness at OLB as he should have been a locker room leader and example setter for the next generation -- like Suggs has been for the Ravens. Woodley fell way short, getting his ring and his money and losing the desire.
James Harrison "final season" with Lamar Woodley, Jason Worilds 3rd season
- 2012: James Harrison 13/13 6 sacks, 0 INT, 1 FR, 2 FF
- 2012: Lamar Woodley 13/13 4 sacks, 1 INT, 1 FR, 1 FF
- 2012: Jason Worilds 16/3 5 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FR, 2 FF
Jason Worilds first season starting with Lamar Woodley final season; Jarvis Jones rookie season (played multiple LB spots)
- 2013: Jason Worilds 16/16 8 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FR, 0 FF
- 2013: Lamar Woodley 11/115 sacks, 0 INT, 1 FR, 1 FF
- 2013: Jarvis Jones 14/8 1 sack
Jason Worilds best season: 2013 8 sacks, 7 of which came from mid season and started to show potential to be great (1st season as starter, 4th in NFL)
Career Highlight/legacy -- shocking early retirement at prime of career; I always thought Worilds to be an enigma, the flashes of talent that would happen but never consistently -- now we know why. At least he didn't "rob" a team by taking a huge contract that put them in cap hell (Woodley) then quitting on them.
Jason Worilds final season with Jarvis Jones first season starting (injured after 3 games), Harrison returning
- 2014: Jason Worilds 16/16 7.5 sacks, 1 INT, 2 FR, 2 FF
- 2014: James Harrison 11/4 5.5 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FR, 0 FF
- 2014: Jarvis Jones 7/3 3 sacks, 0 INT, 0 FR, 1 FF
Jarvis Jones -- TBD.
The "worst of the bunch" was Carlos Emmons -- who's best year with the Steelers was an underwhelming 6 sacks and had a run as a role player at LB for the Eagles. Every other OLB that established themselves on that list had at least one season of 8 sacks; and considering the bashing Jarvis Jones has taken here with the low expectations -- if I were to tell you now he'd have an 8-9 sack regular season, would you be happy with it and take it?