Journey has grown on me a little bit as I've gotten older. I don't like all their songs and they were pretty cheesy at times, but I will say that Steve Perry was a pretty damn good singer in the day. I've always loved KISS since I was a kid and I will always have a soft spot for the band. However I can fully admit that KISS is not the greatest band ever in a technical sense as far as groundbreaking musicianship. They are more about the complete package. The show, the makeup, etc.
Let's face it, musically they were much better in the no makeup years with Bruce Kulick and Eric Carr in the band as opposed to Frehley and Criss. But yeah the package as a whole was so good in the early years and I loved that original lineup. Many of their songs over the years are hit and miss for me, but I appreciate the band. I saw them in '96 during the original lineup reunion. Greatest concert I've ever seen bar none. There isn't even a close 2nd. I thought the top was going to blow off the arena at times from all the explosions and **** flying into the ceiling.
There are plenty of huge, historic bands that people fawn over that I think are just ok. Music is so subjective, which is the beauty of it.