I think your discussion is missing the point. I am not talking absolutes. My analogy is valid for these reasons, engineers that designed and built the hardware and interfaces were not able to get it to perform to their expectations. A couple of kids at a high school who were not getting paid but were passionate about their work were able to do what the professionals could not. In our teams recent past an unknown player that was over looked by the team was recommended by an individual in the steelers family and they picked him up, his name was Willie Parker. The guy that recommended him did not have all the information that is typically produced for the combine prospects, but watched him play. He was not a professional scout. Just a talented guy who's last name is Rooney and saw a player he thought they should take. My point was some of the more involved guys on here ( there are only a few) that do all the research and watch lots of games could probably do a very good job in the scouting departments and could likely put together a better selection on some occasions than our team did. I am not saying every time.