- Joined
- Jun 10, 2014
- Messages
- 10,999
- Reaction score
- 13,092
- Points
- 113
I had a very pleasant exchange with a fellow who tried very hard to help me understand that my fears are all misplaced! The new wave of American progressive liberal is calling NOT for Socialism, but for DEMOCRATIC SOCIALISM.
You know, we already HAVE some Democratic Socialism right here. Social Security, the Police! Stuff like that. So if I could just stop seeing ALL the negative and focus on the positive that expanded democratic socialism could do for me, I would be GREAT.
My response...
@JelliclePat Ok. So you have thrown out the blanket term "democratic socialism" (hereafter referred to as d.s.) as a shield, however you (and the progressive liberal folks advocating for d.s. can't quite put a clear definition of what that would mean in the U.S. Ok, so we know that currently you're definition of d.s. likely includes Social Security, Emergency Services, Public Education through grade 12, Social services like welfare, W.I.C. and unemployment. What else are you planning on adding to the list? Will we be adding Universal Healthcare? What does that entail? Full dental, vision, health checkups, major medical? Do we do that just for citizens, or are we doing that for every breathing soul in the U.S.? If I'm going to give up some 70+ percent of my taxes for this universal healthcare, does that mean I can get cosmetic surgery? Can I get my wife free breast implants? Do I get to stop using generic prescriptions and just get the good brand name stuff? It's all free right? I don't have to pay an extra penny for my healthcare or elective surgery needs, ya?
Then let's talk about free education for everyone. If I'm laid off, can I go back to college, live in the dorms and start working on a few doctorate degrees? Do I get in to any college I want, regardless of my GPA or other measurables? I would kinda like to attend the Air Force Academy. That would be free, right? Will they teach me to fly commercial airliners? Cause I hear that's good work if you can get it. And after I give up a huge chunk of my taxes to send every kid in America to the school of their choosing, Do I need to worry about my job? I mean if a kid graduates in my field and has no debt whatsoever, doesn't that make him a likely cheaper hire than me? I've been working for 20 some odd years, climbed the pay ladder and it seems fair to wonder if I may be replaced by a less experienced but far less expensive option.
But it's ok. Cause we now have "guaranteed income", right? So the 70+ k I make will be simply paid to me whether I can work or not, ya? Cause it's guaranteed income. And obviously if I've gone to college, paid off my loans, worked in my field for years and years MY guaranteed income should be quite a bit higher that somebody who either hasn't gone to college, hasn't had to pay for college, or hasn't worked in their field for a few decades. I mean that's the plan, right?
But, I'm sure I won't have to worry. Cause Bernie Sanders et al. only want to heavily tax people who make just a bit more than they do. So ALL the tax burden is going to fall on folks who make say $400k to $1,000,000+ annually. Well that's GREAT news! Except, how do you keep those folks with all that money from investing in long term opportunities and reducing their trackable income to levels below your cutoff? What keeps them from doing "tax-fu" through their accountants and lawyers so they, like me, find their taxable income juuuust below that high tax rate level?
Oh! I know. We'll tax the BUSINESSES! YA. We'll tax ANY business that is doing well so they can be incentivized to make significant cuts and reductions to avoid being so heavily taxed. We'll politely ask all the big corporations to please leave the U.S. and just head over to Uruguay, or the Czech Republic somewhere and do their business there so they can enjoy the benefits of a global economy without dealing with the repressive tax punishment of the shining bastion of democratic socialism that is America.
Well... If THAT were to happen, I guess we'd have to consider lowering that taxable income level just a bit. But I'm sure it wouldn't end up affecting US! No, those rich folks are happily going to sign up to hand over better than 65% of their income so guys like me can have cosmetic surgery and get implants for my wife. Cause that's my GOD GIVEN AMERICAN RIGHT! You people OWE me breast implants for my wife! YOU OWE ME! I'll just start looking for good surgeons before they all move away.
You know, we already HAVE some Democratic Socialism right here. Social Security, the Police! Stuff like that. So if I could just stop seeing ALL the negative and focus on the positive that expanded democratic socialism could do for me, I would be GREAT.
My response...
@JelliclePat Ok. So you have thrown out the blanket term "democratic socialism" (hereafter referred to as d.s.) as a shield, however you (and the progressive liberal folks advocating for d.s. can't quite put a clear definition of what that would mean in the U.S. Ok, so we know that currently you're definition of d.s. likely includes Social Security, Emergency Services, Public Education through grade 12, Social services like welfare, W.I.C. and unemployment. What else are you planning on adding to the list? Will we be adding Universal Healthcare? What does that entail? Full dental, vision, health checkups, major medical? Do we do that just for citizens, or are we doing that for every breathing soul in the U.S.? If I'm going to give up some 70+ percent of my taxes for this universal healthcare, does that mean I can get cosmetic surgery? Can I get my wife free breast implants? Do I get to stop using generic prescriptions and just get the good brand name stuff? It's all free right? I don't have to pay an extra penny for my healthcare or elective surgery needs, ya?
Then let's talk about free education for everyone. If I'm laid off, can I go back to college, live in the dorms and start working on a few doctorate degrees? Do I get in to any college I want, regardless of my GPA or other measurables? I would kinda like to attend the Air Force Academy. That would be free, right? Will they teach me to fly commercial airliners? Cause I hear that's good work if you can get it. And after I give up a huge chunk of my taxes to send every kid in America to the school of their choosing, Do I need to worry about my job? I mean if a kid graduates in my field and has no debt whatsoever, doesn't that make him a likely cheaper hire than me? I've been working for 20 some odd years, climbed the pay ladder and it seems fair to wonder if I may be replaced by a less experienced but far less expensive option.
But it's ok. Cause we now have "guaranteed income", right? So the 70+ k I make will be simply paid to me whether I can work or not, ya? Cause it's guaranteed income. And obviously if I've gone to college, paid off my loans, worked in my field for years and years MY guaranteed income should be quite a bit higher that somebody who either hasn't gone to college, hasn't had to pay for college, or hasn't worked in their field for a few decades. I mean that's the plan, right?
But, I'm sure I won't have to worry. Cause Bernie Sanders et al. only want to heavily tax people who make just a bit more than they do. So ALL the tax burden is going to fall on folks who make say $400k to $1,000,000+ annually. Well that's GREAT news! Except, how do you keep those folks with all that money from investing in long term opportunities and reducing their trackable income to levels below your cutoff? What keeps them from doing "tax-fu" through their accountants and lawyers so they, like me, find their taxable income juuuust below that high tax rate level?
Oh! I know. We'll tax the BUSINESSES! YA. We'll tax ANY business that is doing well so they can be incentivized to make significant cuts and reductions to avoid being so heavily taxed. We'll politely ask all the big corporations to please leave the U.S. and just head over to Uruguay, or the Czech Republic somewhere and do their business there so they can enjoy the benefits of a global economy without dealing with the repressive tax punishment of the shining bastion of democratic socialism that is America.
Well... If THAT were to happen, I guess we'd have to consider lowering that taxable income level just a bit. But I'm sure it wouldn't end up affecting US! No, those rich folks are happily going to sign up to hand over better than 65% of their income so guys like me can have cosmetic surgery and get implants for my wife. Cause that's my GOD GIVEN AMERICAN RIGHT! You people OWE me breast implants for my wife! YOU OWE ME! I'll just start looking for good surgeons before they all move away.