• Please be aware we've switched the forums to their own URL. (again) You'll find the new website address to be www.steelernationforum.com Thanks
  • Please clear your private messages. Your inbox is close to being full.

Round one - Pickett

I'm noticing that nobody is claiming that Kenny is better than Mitch. Most here making noise like it might be a toss up. Then the pick makes less sense.

And if we just need QB bodies to 'fill holes' you could do that in any round other than the first.

The ONLY reason to pick a QB in the first is if you think he can lead you to the promised land right out of the gate. Instead, as of this moment you just spent your first round pick on your third string QB.

Seriously, this pick was bizarre. I'm telling you, they had their minds set on a guy who went a pick or three before and this was a WTF/panic pick.
Sorry, don’t agree. I believe he was the one they wanted, but didn’t think they would get. When he was there, they may have tried to move back a few spots, but not far enough to lose him. It looks as if it didn’t work out so they took their guy. I’m sure there were 2-3 others they wanted over him, but they were gone.

I am not saying he will be a HOF’er, but I do believe he is going to surprise many haters out there.
 
I'm happy with the pick. I think we got a QB who has some skills that you like to see in a 3rd year as a pro from a young QB. Pickett is very quick at going through his progressions....something you typically don't see from a young NFL QB until Year 3 or 4 as a pro. He's has good pocket awareness and he's a mobile QB who can make plays with his feet too...he ran a 4.62 40 yd dash at the NFL Combine. His accuracy is some of the best I've seen from a college QB....he's not a 1 year starter like many young NFL QB's. Just give him a chance....I'm not concerned about his small hand size...that has been so blown out of proportion. He's going to surprise alot of nay-sayers....just give him a chance. We have a smart QB with a strong enough arm to make all the throws required by an NFL QB. He's a smart passer.
I agree with most of what you’re saying… but it’s Kenny Pickett we know what we’re getting… what if trubisky comes out and seizes the day wins the job. Pickett is 24 if mitch wins the job, he’ll have the job at least a few years Pickett could be 30 before he gets a start! And you can say that’s great but it’s not if it still ties up a 1 draft pick! The other thing is Kenny's too much like Mitch… I just don’t see a huge upside I don’t see so much diffence between them as to use a 1st rd pick on him as a way to improve over Mitch and or Rudy. We have 3 average qbs now how does that improve the Steelers?
 
They got Trubisky. They can get Jimmy G. Mayfield is out there. I think if you draft a 1st round QB, you go for somebody who can be special, not a guy who comps to average QBs. I don't want to be the Vikes with Kirk Couusins year after year. I'd rather draft a guy and he's terrible and you just draft another without wasting years on the false hope of a QB who is merely good.

I really think they should trade Trubisky now. Why keep him? You drafted Pickett to start. Give him the starter's reps. If you don't think he's better than Trubisky then why even draft him?

Rudolph is an OK backup. Bring in another practice squad QB
 
Sorry, don’t agree. I believe he was the one they wanted, but didn’t think they would get. When he was there, they may have tried to move back a few spots, but not far enough to lose him. It looks as if it didn’t work out so they took their guy. I’m sure there were 2-3 others they wanted over him, but they were gone.

I am not saying he will be a HOF’er, but I do believe he is going to surprise many haters out there.
You make a good point… they probably were prepared to trade up. I just think they over sold themselves on fact they had to replace Ben in one fail swoop. As I said earlier Noll never that mistake when Joe Greene retired. I predict right now trubisky wins the job and plays like the 3rd over all draft pick he was drafted to be… makes great passes, runs all over the field throwing darts, Harris runs over defenses claypool and muth live in the end zone johnson goes crazy Pickett never leaves the bench! On defense all the patches fall off, highsmith gets hurt and suks and we are on here going “if we only had drafted defense!“ Lol 😆 Steeler luck!!! Even bears luck they are desperate for trubisky to fail! Lol 😂 either way go Steelers! My parents taught at Pitt wish my dad was here to see this after they passed on Moreno he was never the same 😆 GoSteelers!
 
Sorry, don’t agree. I believe he was the one they wanted, but didn’t think they would get. When he was there, they may have tried to move back a few spots, but not far enough to lose him. It looks as if it didn’t work out so they took their guy. I’m sure there were 2-3 others they wanted over him, but they were gone.

I am not saying he will be a HOF’er, but I do believe he is going to surprise many haters out there.
I don't get the hate. I like Trubisky; I think he's going to play well. But there is certainly no guarantee that will happen. Pickett will be ready to step in and start if he doesn't. The Steelers now have two better options at quarterback than Mason Rudolph...which is a good thing.

They filled in some holes on the offensive line. They're set at running back and tight end. Alualu and possibly Tuitt are coming back to solidify the d-line. They got better at linebacker with Jack. Wallace is an upgrade in the secondary. Sure, there's some depth issues, but they already deftly addressed a lot of the major problems via free agency.

I'm assuming they'll take a wide receiver on day two, so they'll have strengthened the QB room and their weakest position. The best receivers were already gone earlier in the first round; there was no value picking a guy like Watson or Moore at #20. Personally, I probably would have taken Jermaine Johnson and then hoped Ridder would have been there in round two, but I can't blame the Steelers if they believe Pickett is their guy.
 
I can’t believe how Darnold is in his 5th season and is only one year older than Pickett. I hope I’m wrong on this whole situation, but I actually like Mitch a bit and I don’t see why we spent a first rounder on Uncle Rico here. Pickett is literally a grown *** man at this point.
 
Best case scenario would be Mitch gets us into the playoffs, who knows what happens then. Kenny develops this year and is ready to start this year.
We trade mitch for a 2nd rounder next year. Kenny goes on and has an incredible career here.
18 years from now someone on here starts a thread regarding who is the best of our 3 hall of fame QBs
 
I'm noticing that nobody is claiming that Kenny is better than Mitch. Most here making noise like it might be a toss up. Then the pick makes less sense.

And if we just need QB bodies to 'fill holes' you could do that in any round other than the first.

The ONLY reason to pick a QB in the first is if you think he can lead you to the promised land right out of the gate. Instead, as of this moment you just spent your first round pick on your third string QB.

Seriously, this pick was bizarre. I'm telling you, they had their minds set on a guy who went a pick or three before and this was a WTF/panic pick.
How could one claim that? Pickett hasn’t even played a down in the NFL. Trubisky has and actually played 5 years, including a couple playoff games. You would have to be pretty arrogant to make that connection. He will be competing for the starting job. Doesn’t mean he will win it.

And how in the hell did you ascertain that Pickett would be there at 20 before they signed Trubisky? You are the only one that knew then, apparently with clairvoyant powers. Plus I wouldn’t be surprised if Rudolph is traded if he asks for it. Personally I’d prefer they all compete and sort out the order at the end of preseason.

LOL panic pick……sure. Green Bay had the panic pick with Quay Walker in the 1st. He was a early day 2 player at best.
 
Rudolph and Trabisky may have some trade value as preseason starts. Injuries on other teams cause panic.
 
Most of the guys I wanted were gone. Guess there were no trade back partners to be found...crap.
 
The Kenny era has begun. The pick hasn’t sunk in, but I won’t complain. He may very well be the franchise guy. I only hope Tomlin knows wtf he’s doing.


Kenny is in a similar situation as rookie Ben. Behind two veteran QB’s much like Ben was behind Maddox and Batch and a tenured head coach.


Difference is the offensive talent to work with. Hope Najee and the guys can take pressure off of Pickett if he becomes the starter
 
After listening to their press conference some things I gathered. It wasn't close at QB Pickett was their clear choice. They didn't expect him to be available. So the value on the board was greater or equal to the remaining picks. I am going with equal. But all things equal they wanted an option to go with Mitch. I think they see Rudolph as a backup. So they didn't want to be stuck with a possible starter and a backup at the most critical position on the roster.

If you glue into their thinking you should understand the pick even if you don't care for it.
 
Last edited:
So, riddle me this; why sign Mitch if you're going to draft a 24 YO rookie who you ran out in front of the cameras to proclaim 'NFL ready'? Do you need a 'bridge QB' or don't you? If you do, and Kenny is as NFL ready as he's going to be, then does he have no upside?

I don't get it at all. Maybe everyone else they actually wanted got washed off their board and they panicked? AND, they couldn't traded out of the first round, picked up another pick or two, and still got this stiff. Stunningly stupid pick.
I didn't want a QB but when they signed Mitch, they didn't know their top QB would come anywhere near falling to them at 20. He did, Davis was gone, many of the top WR's were gone, so it made the pick pretty obvious - having Mitch or not.
 
Hopefully, they sit Pickett for a year but we shall see. If he outperforms in the preseason, then they may put him in right off the bat.
 
I agree with most of what you’re saying… but it’s Kenny Pickett we know what we’re getting… what if trubisky comes out and seizes the day wins the job. Pickett is 24 if mitch wins the job, he’ll have the job at least a few years Pickett could be 30 before he gets a start! And you can say that’s great but it’s not if it still ties up a 1 draft pick! The other thing is Kenny's too much like Mitch… I just don’t see a huge upside I don’t see so much diffence between them as to use a 1st rd pick on him as a way to improve over Mitch and or Rudy. We have 3 average qbs now how does that improve the Steelers?
Pickett will be the entrenched starter before this season is over. Tomlin can't stand to be wrong, there will be no fair competition
 
I didn't want a QB but when they signed Mitch, they didn't know their top QB would come anywhere near falling to them at 20. He did, Davis was gone, many of the top WR's were gone, so it made the pick pretty obvious - having Mitch or not.
If anyone was interested in any position other than a QB, the first round fell in the worst way possible for the Steelers. Just about every possible target was gone.
 
I'm usually not here nor there when it comes to draft picks. In my roughly 40 years of fandom, this is the first pick I utterly hate.
 
If anyone was interested in any position other than a QB, the first round fell in the worst way possible for the Steelers. Just about every possible target was gone.
You knew the way the draft went with Davis gone and the huge run on WR's, that the pick was definitely going to be QB. It was just a matter of which one. The Steelers must have just loved Pickett all along because Willis' arm and athleticism looked very enticing at the combine and his pro day.
 
If anyone was interested in any position other than a QB, the first round fell in the worst way possible for the Steelers. Just about every possible target was gone.
Booth, McDuffie and even Elam were there. This was a rich CB class at the top and we had a shot at 3 players that normally aren't available at 1.20.

Guess the same.goes for QB, almost never the top QB is available at 1.20, I don't know, hope I'm wrong on Pickett and he becomes a true franchise player.
 
Booth, McDuffie and even Elam were there. This was a rich CB class at the top and we had a shot at 3 players that normally aren't available at 1.20.

Guess the same.goes for QB, almost never the top QB is available at 1.20, I don't know, hope I'm wrong on Pickett and he becomes a true franchise player.
I think they saw equal value. And with their track record at drafting corners that wasn't without risk as well. They have three capable corners and one capable QB or they are hoping. If you are looking at a value and mixing in greatest weakness. It makes perfect sense.
 
So, riddle me this; why sign Mitch if you're going to draft a 24 YO rookie who you ran out in front of the cameras to proclaim 'NFL ready'?
Because we needed a back up QB and our current one sucked.
 
Top